Donna had three seconds of screen time and landed the best sight gag of the night.

The fact that Goliath is a Great Dane and Kim and Lindsay thought they ran over a squirrel :)

Modern dads are different from dads of the past? These guys are a reflection of modern dads? These guys are hip???

Haha. Guess I'll have to subscribe or wait. Choices.

Episode is not available to download in iTunes yet for some reason.

The first time I saw this episode I hated it because I found it so painful to watch. Now it's among my top three favorites largely for the reasons that Todd outlined in his review. I love the scenes with Lindsay and the mathletes. She is so at ease around them as opposed to how trying she is with the freaks. The…

I had pants that color when I was 13 or so. My parents made me wear them when I was supposed to be dressed up.

As much as I totally love PNR I think Louis CK has much better things to do than hang around Pawnee.

Jocks don't know how to tell jokes.

I'm glad that you give the good details of the commentary. I try to watch TV/movies with commentary but I get bored even when there's interesting info. The cold open in this episode is one of my favorites.

I moved across the country in the middle of the 5th grade. The neighborhood that I moved to was rural and had very few kids whereas kids ran rampant in my old neighborhood. I knew in 6th grade that I was a little too old to be trick or treating, but I decided to go anyway remembering how much fun it was in my old…

I don't know about the religious aspect, but all my friends that grew up in the Detroit area claim that Halloween is a bigger deal in Michigan than other places.

If I got to pick I'd choose:

Neal has tons of great lines, but Bill getting drunk is one of the highlights of the series. I pick Martin Starr.

Hey Haverchuck, what ya doing Friday night?

There's a reason that we're part of the TV/film obsessed sub-commentariat.

This is not a party story, but it's about the first time I got drunk. I skipped school with two of my friends and we hung out at the mall all day, then went back to one of their houses where 4 bottles of pink Boone's Farm were chilling in the refrigerator. After I downed a bottle and half of the stuff we drove to a…

You were Diane Court from Say Anything?

What about Joan's delivery of "It's better than getting screwed by you" to Pete Campbell in front of Peggy? On the nose, yes. Brilliant, yes.

Sundays bring out the best and brightest of the AV Club.