I feel a little disloyal to Josh Charles upvoting this.

What is with you people and joking about a Sports Night resurrection? Stop toying with my emotions!

I don't know. Whatever they did, they should try it again!

And I don't think anyone's mentioned recruit Stephen Fishbach! You can be the kind of person who gets really into Survivor (and is good at it) without already being a fan.

We keep mentioning it because it keeps being there.

That seems so reasonable! Julie was terrible, terrible casting. I'm angry at the powers that be for putting someone on the show who wasn't invested in the game, but not caring about Survivor doesn't make you a bad person.

Yeah, I wasn't sure what was going on either. I kind of thought they all packed up the food at random just to carry it back to camp, so what Julie had in her bag wasn't like an even share that had been distributed to her or something only she had thought to grab. We didn't see them eating the other food they brought…

But they look really alike! It's too confusing!

I really, really, really do not understand quitter hate. We're watching people be miserable in a variety of ways for a slim chance of winning a million dollars. They're hungry and cold and sleeping badly and lonely and they can't ever really relax and they know that when the show airs they're likely in for some public…

Didn't we learn from Misfits not to mix telekinesis and dairy?

I think it's a problem for Grace and for their relationship that Alicia is lying and making Grace a part of it, but talking to Grace about religion doesn't seem out of line. Grace isn't a child. I don't think there's anything wrong with treating your reasonably-well-adjusted adolescent daughter like someone who can…

Disgruntled Goat cares!

I could do very well with all the New Yorkers, but I'm from upstate and would feel strange claiming people from the city.

Really? I seem to remember later seasons where some partial breaks didn't count. I think they sometimes specify how many corners have to be disconnected. Maybe the issue in Australia was that they didn't have a clear rule?

Weirder to be stuck sleeping in a Survivor cuddle puddle with your sex partner or the person you're abstaining with?

I am not good at this game.

Probst. Eat Probst. He has more meat on him and doesn't smell as bad! And you could keep the clean clothes!

What you said. They weren't bailed out by Survivor magic at all. They pretty much traded their whole shelter for food, then built a much more pitiful shelter, then had it destroyed in a rain storm that washed away the rice. The sighting and rescue of the new rice seemed legit since it wasn't somewhere easy to see or…

I just watched Australia for the first time and even with all the joking about it I was amazed by the extent of Jeff's crush on Colby. He kept showing up at the rewards Colby won just to hang out and gaze at him! And it still wasn't the most blatant Colby crush of the season!

I mean tweeting about Survivor. Is she breaking the rules?