Jimmy’s reading of Chuck’s letter was quite cold, but the words Chuck wrote were such total bullshit, I am not sure I can blame him.   Not a single word rang true for me, or at least I can’t see them coming out of the mouth of the character we saw over the last few seasons.   It is interesting the letter wasn’t…

You summed it up: Prestige Television. That plus Amy Adams plus highly exaggerated, highly dramatic and emotionally wrought characters equals catnip for the Gillian Flynn audience, one that’s willing to overlook absurd stock figures and implausible events in a Faulkner-meets-Mayberry town (with a downtown that despite…

I’ve brought up the same questions of her being a contortionist. Even if she was one, there is still no way she could reach some of those areas on her back and legibly write words. Make scratches sure, but write not a chance. So, either that was what happened after the train...the players held her down and carved…

Another thing that bothers me, perhaps it will be shown later, Camille has scars on her back. There is no way anyone could ever write things on their back. Perhaps slash some parts of their back, but not as much coverage as she has. So, either someone went to town on her back with a razor or there’s some BS in that.

I honestly don’t get what’s the big deal with the letter, neither within the show or in the review. Like, Jimmy’s non-reaction is supposed to be proof that he is now fully dehumanized or something? It was just a bullshit courtesy letter Chuck has put together out of duty with no feelings involved whatsoever, neither…

It’s hard for me to pin down what exactly caused her reaction. Was it Jimmy’s lack of reaction to the letter? Was it guilt over the Mesa Verde case? I didn’t even pick up those at first, really; I almost felt like it was regret for the loss of a time when Chuck might have actually meant the things in that letter, a…

“Just a large cheese pizza...sliced.”

And then it took Camille ALL day to get to her mother’s house, but the roller skate girls can get across town in minutes?  Wind Gap has some expanding contracting borders or something.

that bothered me deeply, the timing there.

I’m sorry, I had high hopes for this, but this is the most ridiculous series I’ve seen in ages. From Patricia Clarkson’s dinner-theatre Streetcar Named Desire performance (and getting some competition in this episode from Elizabeth Perkins), the ASMR sound design, ‘you’re reading me’, Camille Preaker making certain to…

Interviewed by The Sydney Morning Herald, Vince Gilligan reveals “I want to know more about Kim, I want to see and learn more about her. If we were to do another spin-off it would be the Kim Wexler show.”

I couldn’t disagree with you more there. I absolutely do not think Jimmy’s a sociopath. If he were, he would have played the old woman in the assisted living without any sense of guilt. Nothing he’s done fits in with what I know about the clinical manifestations of being a sociopath or a psychopath. Jimmy’s not a…

Still with this?

Chuck was horrible to jimmy, he got his own brother suspended and just barely avoided jail. Kim knows very well why jimmy doesn’t care, that is why she feels so protective of him, she feels really sorry for him. In her eyes, jimmy cared for chuck for years, put up with all his insanity, and all chuck did was…

I love Kim.

I may have asked this question before, or just thought I did but wondering how old Camille is supposed to be? Is she early 30's? Late 30's?. When Ashley the cheerleader (with apparently a damaged ear) said she idolized her growing up it was a confusing statement given that I thought Camille left Wind Gap before Amma…

Someone more astute can correct me but has Camille been wearing the same clothes every day since she’s arrived in Wind Gap, notwithstanding the white dress she wore on Calhoun Day?

This was frustrating bad, magnified by how good everything else has been. I’m fucking DONE with Amma. The whole “poor me I’m tortured and alone that’s why I do oxy and blast Frankie Vallie” character arctype is 100% bullshit. Are we supposed to feel pity for her? Because even though it’s awful, I truly wish this…

Is the show trying to replicate the real-time experience of reading the book? 8 hours is an awfully long running time for an adaptation of a 250-page book, but I think 8 hours might be the average read time for a novel of that size.

Wish you guys wrote on the whole season! Would have loved a week to week recap. Anyways I’m watching it per your recommendation and holy hell is it a lot better and funnier than I was expecting. The ads did this show NO favors; they sold it as a straight up drama, when this is way more like Veep (did someone work on…