You let them get on with it as long as the jokes are somewhat funny and not too insulting.

Costas is still mad they haven't made soapboxing an Olympic event.

You must be joking. I really hope you're joking. Are you joking?

I, too, think AIDS jokes are out of bounds. If I were DougExeter, I'd have deleted this and every other comment I'd ever made. So I hope you'll believe me when I tell you, non-facetiously, that I hope you contract AIDS.

"A season-saver? "Carolina came into its game against the Saints with a 10-4 record.

Will there be a COTY post at some point? Can you make Raysism second again?

Raysism: [nothing]

It would have been 64 but he rimmed out a five footer.

You must be joking. I really hope you're joking. Are you joking?

Nobody did Wake Up Deadspin better.

That's right, let's forever immortalize a trollish parody by one of the site's funnier commenters, but not acknowledge any of the creative and genuinely brilliant humorists that came before him. If anything, the DHoF should honour the Deadspin Commenter who pre-Kinja, was a staple of the site and provided an ideal…

I'm conflicted on how to vote... if only there were some other commenters here to moralize to me & others about how we don't "get" the site the same way they do if we vote no...

Wait, what happened to my fucking star?!

Only starred commenters can vote

You must be joking. I really hope you're joking. Are you joking?

You can't be serious. I really hope you're not serious. Are you serious?

You must be joking. I really hope you're joking. Are you joking?

You can't be serious. I hope you're not serious. Are you serious?

Ken Tarr called me a short while later and asked what he would have to do to get a job at Deadspin.