Is it still a “blown call” when they take several minutes to review the damn thing, and then decide they got it right the first time? I feel like at that point, it becomes...something else.

Yeah, I feel like it’s often an unpopular opinion, but how about we enforce the rules consistently, all the time?

Your colleagues at Jalopnik have been on the case since the incident. There’s video:

There were a couple of these at the home-based day care I attended as a kid. I had no idea what they were.

I definitely have mixed feelings about all of the possible solutions. It’s all in the execution, I guess.

I...don’t understand.

Fair enough, though I would personally exempt Georgiou Prime from that list. Everyone knew she was doomed before the show even aired.

Also, I don’t think I want to live in a universe in which you have to ask for consent before you save someone’s life.*

Yeah, you’re right that it’s more than that, but at worst, it’s still a case of doing the right thing for the wrong(ish) reasons.

Yeah, he’s seen DS9. He says in the review that he hasn’t seen VOY or ENT.

Kate Mulgrew deserved better than what they wrote for her.

They established pretty definitively that there is - Tilly’s the captain. That’s why they had to repaint the ship and synthesize the uniforms.

Sure, I think that makes perfect sense. Too many action movies will make you sick of action movies. Too many romantic comedies will make you sick of romantic comedies. I’ve been a comics fan for decades, but even I’ve given up on seeing every single superhero movie that comes out. But I have no issues with them…

pooped the trunk

Yup, I had that thought as well. My best guess is they just updated it based on all the Klingon signals they were able to detect?

To follow up a bit, here’s the official timeline:

It’s a popular theory, based on aesthetics (people point to the bridge windows, as well). However, the producers have said repeatedly that DSC is set in the “Prime” timeline, not the Kelvin Timeline.

Rescuing an enemy from certain death, even against their will, seems pretty in line with those “traditional Starfleet values” people have been bemoaning the lack of in this series.

There have been conflicting behind-the-scenes explanations for her, but the consensus seems to be that she’s a cybernetically-augmented human.

The reason I do this is the temporal war would have changed things enough that 2011's Star Trek wouldn’t have existed in the first place... no? Or do people not consider Star Trek to be canon for the Tv-verse like every other movie was?