100% agree. From top down it’s not Superman. In any aspect of the word.

Thanks for clarifying that. I already had the Batman one so I just didn’t notice it with the Compiled edition.

Oh on that we agree 400% lol. It was horrible and I’ve tried to rewatch it several times. Every time I have the same issues. The only thing I liked was the very beginning on Krypton lol.

Same with you, I feel that sometimes having a ton of background knowledge to understand 5 issues worth of reading is a headache. I’ve been there myself a times. It’s why I formulated my opinion about it lol.

Which one, the Batman collected volume with the Mask? Or the compiled edition?

So what makes him different than a Villain then? Seriously think about it. You’re looking at it from the “what if I were him,” point of view. Which is valid and what Whedon intended. However, look at Banner’s character. Who he is, and not who you are. Banner wouldn’t threaten anyone. The Hulk would. Not Bruce Banner.…

Tony Stark grew up as a human. A human that created weapons that led to deaths of hundreds of combatants and innocent civilians. He knew what would happen putting on that Armor and he still did it anyway. He took the risks knowing collateral damage was a part of the game and in his first film, failed to think about…

I don’t disagree with your logic. However I found the main story easy to follow without the tie-ins. The other issue is that you’re dealing explicitly with a cross-over series dealing with Batman en total. It was advertised that way. The main Batman book was the thrust of the story, but there are side-plots and…

She walks in and starts spouting. Banner looks at her and states “I can snap your neck, and I don’t even have to change shades to do it.”

Uh no. Not it does not. Bruce Banner is a complete emotional control character. Has been for years. Whedon set this up the entire time that he was reluctant to use any sort of force for 2 films. He placed himself in self-exile for that reason. It was why he even shied away from being used in the opening brawl when…

It still impacts his character arc though, deleted or not. It was out of character for him, or any Marvel hero to threaten lethal force.

This shot is so Epic. Makes me feel like a kid all over again going “I wanna be an X-Wing pilot!” And having a X-Wing Squadron street sign on my bedroom door.

If you’re referring to the Elevator scene. He then immediately smashes it over the Hulk with bystanders, the very ones he just rescued, 5 feet away. The moments where he checked for collateral damage, doesn’t equate the destruction they still caused blasting through buildings and such.

Because Stark has had experience with the situations. He knows what to do. Clark didn’t. I’ll be the first to jump down MoS’s throat for being a bad Superman film, but you can’t fault one film versus 5. Especially when in the first Iron Man Tony isn’t worried about casualties. He does in the 2nd film and so forth.…

This is one of the most 90’s-esque panels I have seen in comics in a long time. I can’t help but laugh at where this is heading.

They released an uber edition for $30 bucks that has everything in it. The tie-ins were important because it was the Death of the FAMILY. Without the Tie-Ins it wouldn’t have worked. The Catwoman one was especially important because she called out Joker on his love for Batman and why she has had to bury her own…

lol I’m with you there. People have been taking MoS (even though I hated the film) to task for this and it is unfair. This is Iron Man’s 5th on screen rodeo with keeping people in check. Cap’s 4th. THOR’s 4th, etc. They’ve been “saving” people for a ton of films while we only got one film where Clark first had to…

That’s your only quibble? Good one I admit, but the only one?

Does her collar say Puddin? As in she’s wearing a collar with her nickname for the Joker on it? That’s um...that’s touching on some interesting Psychological issues lol.

I hear you on Superman III. However, Marvel had their burn-out in the 90’s. Everyone knows that story. Yet the Superhero genre in general did by the time Batman and Robin came out.