We saw Nathan get his ass beat down like, earlier the same day. There’s no way he’s that badly decomposed over the course of an evening.

I’m pretty sure Chloe and Max are ‘star crossed lovers’, not unlike Chloe and Rachel (based on multiple outbursts from Chloe in this episode, I’m now 100% certain that she and Rachel were lovers). As Mari points out, she has three bullets around her necklace, meaning she’s presumably going to die 3 times to gunshot…

That’s what I was thinking...Chloe and Max talked about the smell, and I doubt that would be true so quickly. Maybe Nathan is just tied up somewhere? Jefferson has his phone, and obviously wanted to throw Max off the trail...but then the photo of Nathan with Rachel Amber...was he somehow in collusion with Jefferson?…

My brother thought Nathan could be the Rachwl corpse Max and Chloe finds in episode 4 since the two haven’t looked at the body closely. However, Nathan hasn’t been seen for half a day, so the body can’t be him as it is decomposing. Maybe Mr. Jefferson killed him at the barnshortly before Max and Chloe gets there. I…

I dont what that to happen... but its kind of clear that in each reality Chloe has to die one way or another.

I hate that.

I want an episode 6 with just fan service. I need that after this cliff hanger!!!

Stella says that she’s pretty sure Mr. Jefferson and Rachel Amber slept together, though the phone conversation is suspect in retrospect as well.

Hmm, it is true, we haven’t seen Nathan in a while...my impression is that the body has been in the ground for a while, too, though, so it probably can’t be him...right?

I was one of the few who blamed Mr Jefferson when I could...never trusted that guy! I’m still undecided if the body in the hole is Rachel Amber, Nathan, or someone else, but I can’t wait to find out.

From the get go I felt like that dude was was a little too keyed into the students’ lives and was a little bit creepy because of it, but damn I didn’t think he was that kind of a dirt bag. I gotta say that this turn really cements this series as a top contender for game of the year so far, and shows that while the…

That’s why one of the videos I link with a playthrough has over two million views. They’re all meeeee.

My only reaction to this was “WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK??”

Yes, the screenshot I use for ‘finding Rachel Amber’s body’ is from the end of the episode, not when they originally find it. Was having a hard time finding that exact moment in the footage I captured, but the point is, they found the damn body and it was a shocker!

ugh, I hate how much I like it that Chloe says that.

The ending of this episode though. Woah.

I just finished this episode a couple of hours ago and it still has me feeling pretty much like shit.

This episode was intense. Once I realized where Chloe was going in that alternate timeline conversation I started to tear up a little. This was like saying goodbye to Lee or shooting Kenny in the Walking Dead all over again. And that ending, I never saw that coming, and even worse that I couldn’t stop it from…

It’s an adventure game, a game genre that has been around since the mid 70s.

Don’t.

I love how this game makes me rethink myself over and over as a person. When I came to this choice, looking from Max’s perspective it felt like there was no right answer so I had to dig deep into my morals and ended up refusing to do it. I chose that because whenever there is an uncertain future (In this case being…