I do.

Love We Can Work It Out, but While My Guitar Gently Weeps is a masterpiece.

Sorry, but Revolution beats Rocky Raccoon any day of the week. Speaking of which, how about Eight Days a Week as a runner-up for E? Ooh, this game is so much fun!

Many, many good picks here. You're Gonna Lose That Girl - oh, yeah. Which reminds me of I'll Get You, the B/W of She Loves You.

Love, love, love Any Time at All. And its B/W, The Things We Said Today.

A Day in the Life is truly a masterpiece, but I would pick And Your Bird Can Sing and And I Love Her as runner-ups. Too many good songs to pick just one for each letter.

How is "She Loves You" not up there?

I thought "Roger's dead" was the funniest line in the show. I couldn't stop laughing. As I recall it, it wasn't a brief back and forth. It was open the door, the guy asks, "Where's Roger," and Louie replies, "Roger's dead." And slams the door in his face. Cracked me up. And I immediately decided that the next…

Carrie Preston is Michael Emerson's wife.

SPOILER: Mikhail killed Charlie. He didn't get beat up enough.

I disagree with your point of Ben wanting to stay there above all else. We saw, from his secret room as well as the Tunisian hotel having him as a VIP, that Ben left the island often. All those suits, passports, different currencies.

I agree. Just finished a rewatch, and I enjoyed the sideways world so much more, knowing what it was.

The beauty of the sideways world was that we got to see our heroes have good lives, and make good choices, as opposed to the lousy lives and choices they had in real life. It was a nice break from the 5 years of misery Darlton gave us for them.

I like that. I'd prefer to believe that, too. Let's just say that if Darlton claims on-island Dave wasn't MiB, they were wrong. My way makes it a better story, and connects it better to the ultimate plan.

I believe it was stated by Darlton that MiB was not the apparition of Ben's mother. MiB needed a dead body on-island in order to take shape as someone, and Ben's mom died in Portland.

I totally agree with you. That's why I assumed that Dave on-island was MiB. But someone else pointed out that Darlton said that Dave was not MiB, and I checked this on Lostpedia. They did in fact state this. But they also stated that Dave was not Libby's husband, as the OP stated. So I don't know. To me,…

What I'm saying is that Jacob knew that Nadia was about to be murdered by Widmore's men, and was there for Sayid at that moment. I don't think he was trying to manipulate him into going back to the island. He knew he'd be back. If anything, Nadia's murder manipulated Sayid into killing for Ben, not going back to…

I did rewatch the episode a few weeks ago, and there is no indication of what you say. Just to be sure, I just checked Lostpedia, and Darlton confirmed that it was Richard, not MiB, who chose Ben to be leader. They even mentioned the similarity of both Locke and Ben having to kill their fathers first. MiB certainly…

According to Lostpedia, Darlton said that Dave was a figment of Hurley's imagination. The name Dave referred to Hurley's father, not Libby's husband.

No need to get nasty. As others in this discussion have noted, it was obvious to many at the time, and widely discussed. Since you were watching at a different time, perhaps you missed the connection because you weren't obsessively discussing every aspect of the show on The Fuselage (a popular board at the time) all…