Boy you said it, you nailed it on the head. Rosie did have some great character development, I forgot about that. And I don't fault the other guy for disliking it, it's too bad he doesn't see what we see in the game, but to each their own. All this talk about VC is giving me a hankering to play it again, I had already…

Again, by your logic and from I gather on what you say, you must hate just about everything then. Whether formulaic or not, most stories follow a similar plot line. Sure you have those gems in there once in a while that present something different, but I feel you are being over critical. You're criticizing it for…

But then you are submitting that it is only good or bad by your authority. That you are the end all decider of what is good or bad. Its all opinions, there is no one right way or wrong way. I like it because it is good, and many other people think the same thing and probably have just as good arguments why its good as…

Again, we disagree, to me it is top 12 material. Hands down, no argument about it. Also, for argument sake, tell me any other story were you actually see someone get together with someone mid story and then we see their relationship struggles throughout the rest of the story? Most stories focus on the chase and the…

You can try and that's where you state your side, but again, this is the internet. People come here with their mind made up. It's near impossible to make anyone think differently. Trust me I know. After you make your argument I say leave it at that because going beyond that just seems to eventually lead to flame wars.…

SPOILER ALERT: Welkin does end up with her, that's how the game ends. They have a kid together. Maybe you missed that. One of the best endings to a love story in a game yet.

I do agree that PS3 has better and more varied exclusives than the 360.

That may be so, but there are also tons and tons of people who like the game and could care less what you find to be bad about it. They just enjoyed it, doesn't have to make sense to you, it just is. So you gotta respect that just like I am respecting your viewpoint. You are borderline becoming annoying now and…

Again, that's your opinion, most would seem to disagree, me included. What you see, I don't. I loved every moment of it. I'm not a hug CoD fan but I still respect what it has done for the genre of shooters. I think when you dislike something a lot of people like, you have to respect that, that you just disagree and…

I get where you're coming from, but I also enjoyed the challenge of trying to beat the levels quickly. It just made more replay value for me.

Well, I gotta disagree, the story is one of the best to me, I do like anime though. But I thought it was very well made. It was very emotional and real while being over the top at times too. I loved it. To each their own.

Again, I thought the acting was fine and and the story was great. I do not share your views of the them. All in all the game was a top 10 for the PS3 for me. I'm fine with you not liking it, but it changes nothing for me and you need to respect that too.

I find it interesting that you didn't like it but you did like Indigo Prophecy. Having played that you should have understood that the gameplay was going to be unconventional. As far as the story goes I guess to each their own. I loved it, so we just disagree.

What was the problem with the scoring system? Or what did you not like about it? Just curious. I know some people don't like it because it makes them feel like they need to rush through the battles. Not sure if that is your reason though.

To each their own. It's a unique game and either you like it or you don't Indigo Prophecy was the game before it on the PS2 and that game was unique too. One of my favorites though. But the controls or gameplay probably aren't for everyone.

Again, that is your opinion, which I still feel is the minority. I have never even heard negative things about Heavy Rain until this thread here.

That was my thinking for a list of games that define a system. Must plays, they almost should all be exclusives. And honestly, if you were gonna put a CoD title, why that one? Aren't they much better by now with more features? I gave up on that series a few titles back, I think Modern Warfare 2 was my last. Not a…

I'm on the fence about Uncharted 2 or 3, not sure which I thought was better. Uncharted 2 was such a leap from 1 but 3 was on par 2 I think, that's why I think either would be fine. In the case of this list I would almost recommend 2 because then you could logically move on to 3 if you liked it, I only recommend for…

I know right? People forget about it because it was such an early release (pre trophies) but it's still one of the best PS3 games you'll ever play, if not one of the most unique games in general you'll play. There is nothing like it.

Well that's your opinion and I respect that, but you are in the minority with that opinion. It is regarded by most as one of the best PS3 games out there. I for one loved the plot, it had me guessing until the last minute.