The Potter films knocked every single casting choice out of the park. Absolutely definitive.

Duuuuude, I've been saying that for years. He's probably too old now, sadly, or at least will be by the time the Batman movies get back around to a "silly" villain like Freeze.

I dunno, I've not heard people complain that William's music tends to distract, yet much of it certainly sounds great on its own.

Her biological clock is ticking like this.

Giving Chewie some story and history would be great. But I'm skeptical about the Wookiee idea for two reasons.

This is why I feel kinda bad for Jedi. Being the weakest of the originals is not entirely it's own fault. It was Empire's decision to end on a cliffhanger that left Han in the clutches of an extraneous subplot with no relation to the central story/Empire. And then Jedi had to spend an hour cleaning up that mess before…

What's terrible is that, after spending years bitching about the '97 special editions, I would give anything to have them back over the '04 ultimate editions.

Yeah… to my shame I was one of them. Skipped school to sit in my car all day in a time before smartphones. And fwiw the very very first midnight showing did sell out to us campers, but otherwise there was no reason not to get opening day tickets at the door.

Alright well maybe we can agree to disagree about the awesomeness of Lapti Nek as a piece of music. But what's certain is that Lapti Nek has the appropriate ambience for the scene. It's spaced out and sleezy, just as Jabba's palace should be. Jedi Rocks is way too contemporary, almost county-western. It wrecks the…

TAKE IT BACK

It was weird, but I don't blame Carrey himself so much. He may have been the perfect choice for Riddler under a director that didn't see the whole premise as a joke.

True. And they'll probably work out a deal on that once they have the other five. But the point is there's nothing they can do about it for now.

ATTN: EVERYBODY YELLING AT DISNEY TO RELEASE THE ORIGINAL VERSIONS

It's very nice, but a rather jarring stylistic change.

He was my pick for Legolas. I doubt he was ever considered, even by himself, but he would have been awesome.

He actually more handsome than the guy who's famous for being handsome

Frat house Xbox gamers.

With respect to Martin Freeman, obviously 1970s Ian Holm would have been the greatest Bilbo of all time.

Except swap out Prinze Jr. for Marc Blucas.

Back when they were casting TDK I was rooting for Crispin Glover. Still curious how that would have turned out.