It’s set in a world similar to our world, NOT our world. Deal with it.

Perhaps you are the one being lazy. Instead of absorbing the author’s own creative history, you plant your foot, huff and puff, and say, “no no no”, no creativity or fiction allowed here. Everything MUST be REAL!

Glad you can Read J.K. R.’s mind ... must be nice to have that magical power... go find a non-fictional category, I really think you need to be there, rather than here in the fictional area.

“The “real world” automatically means our world. That’s what I meant by “real world.” Otherwise, I wouldn’t have used the words “real world.””

Bingo! Thanks ... I have been curious about why it matters for years ... your explanation sheds a light on the topic that I had not considered, thank you.

:chuckle: Fair enough. :-)

I counter Good Sir:

Ok, yes.

The story logic needs to hold within the boundaries of the story writers world(mind). What is being discussed has not been defined by J. K. R., so it does not go against the story logic.

“They have been about a secret magical society living among the real world.”

Is it? Where in the annals of fiction writing does it say that fictional stories are based in our reality, and that since they are that they must coincide with our reality, ya know, here in reality?

Sorry, no.

Let me correct your sentence ...

Common, not same.

Fiction is not logical.

He is a she, and no.

“...hastily written...”

It’s on ...

Man, I am glad you told me that. And here all this time, I thought skinwalkers were fictional. Damn good to know they are real.

“(1) The Skinwalkers are not considered fictional by the tribes. They are “real” to them as Jesus Christ is to Christians.”