They are, but heads up: snarky sarcasm isn't ok on the forum

Yeah, I can see that. There are a few people here who make interesting observations…and I don't mean rah-rah show necessarily, but genuinely thoughtful criticism, which I appreciate. But if you want more of that type of deep analysis do check out TSatS. Lani and Alastair are both book readers, but many of their…

You want to hurt someone over a TV show? Wow. You probably should stop watching; that's extreme.

To say that Claire isn't the main protagonist betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of the story. And I'm not really interested in debating anything with you, thanks.

Or Watson in Sherlock Holmes. Yes, I'm aware of those types of narrators. Claire isn't one of them, as most book readers seem to understand.

I hear you.

It felt like the inevitable conclusion to their relationship.

Jamie rubbed his head while taking about his relationship with Dougal in The Gathering; it was most definitely in the books. As far as my comments, it's a public forum. I'm free to comment where I like, and so are you, though you should of course not feel obligated to respond.

Throw out some plausible explanations for it, and I might be persuaded. As it is, I deliberately used "literally" because I don't see any.

Yeah, this person's need for the show to be a terrible failure despite available evidence, is getting to be absurd.

Another lifetime? It happened. And Jamie is suspicious all along of Dougal's involvement in bashing his head in. Dougal confirms this on his deathbed. So not really a surprise, though well written.

Plus, he suspected Dougal had brained him a few years prior. They were definitely frienemies.

There's that justification I was expecting…94% critic rating must not be up to your exacting standards lol.

+1 for "poops rainbows"

Agree.

It's fine when used correctly ;-)

They're on the Season 2 page. The link is right there. I don't know what else to tell you.

If you're having trouble navigating RT, it suddenly makes sense that you've missed several elements of the story here. Read for comprehension :-)

I provided the link for a reason.

http://www.metacritic.com/t…