Visually it looks pretty good and the music and directing is good and producing a mood. That, I imagine is what atmospheric means.

This. 24 is a damn good comparison. I wonder if these people like only have 2 settings "Serious show" and "not serious show" and so they can like the Flash because it's basically unwatchably dumb, and they can like Breaking Bad because it's smart, but they can't like TWD because it's "not that smart". It's like 24…

Negan's character is a leader who ascended to power through luck, confidence, a twisted sense of humor, and rules. He is a guy who needs to confidently believe the people beneath him's rebellious senses are crushed and he achieves this by stately clearly how he behaves and using his superior manpower to immediately…

This show hasn't earned that. Save that for FTWD, which genuinely is much dumber. Lots of people still like this show. At least be insightful, looks to me like you are just hopping on the hate bandwagon for the fun of it.

Seriously, this comments section is ridiculous. It's like you aren't allowed to even like the show here.

"That's as breezy as a fart box in September"
"It's like we went fishing and caught a dildo"
"Well, Monkey Poop"
"As dirty as a hair otter"
"Light up their asses like birthday cakes"
"Rick may have some ichy balls, but he knows where the sun rises"

Jesus, a reviewer should not be reviewing a show where they seem to hate everything about it. This episode did a great job surprising me, and for a show like this that is huge. I am scared of Neegan, around him, characters do not seem to have plot armor watching these people fight to survive is where the entertainment…

Self awareness isn't his strong suit. More likely is he will turn on her on a dime if she dumps him.

Made my skin crawl. Totally accurate though, Cartman does 1000 things to pander to Heidi and then she starts doing a couple to pander back.

I know. I really wish the people here would take a step back. They seem like reasonable enough people so how the South Park and SNL reviewers can get this blindly obsessed with talking about Trump (and how Trump isn't being insulted enough) and not notice they are this rabid about it is baffling to me. I feel like if…

Butters is great. He's been more upset lately so it's great to see classic happy niave cooperative Butters too.

I think you might be on to something. It's not like we've been sticklers for 1-to-1 comparisons in all other aspects of the show.

I love the Airport Hilton gag. Relatively speaking the Airport Hilton has practically been advertised positively by South Park.

What this show probably does best is show not just characters but how characters understand other characters. That is one benefit of the clone X playing clone Y, it shows what character attributes stand out to X relative to Y. And the dream shows what Helena thinks is normal and what she thinks is normal to the other…

The biggest tell between Rachel and Sarah seems to be the walk. Sarah has a more "man-ish" walk, whereas Rachel always has a very soft step. I do feel like for fan service we are heading more and more towards things like "Sarah playing Rachel playing Allison".

Can somebody explain why Sarah went as Rachel and Allison went as Sarah? Aside from the writers wanting Sarah to be Rachel later wouldn't it make a hell of a lot more sense if they were just trying to trick people to have Allison play Rachel and Sarah play Sarah? Allison is a lot closer in demeanor to Rachel than…

I think he has the capacity to be the funniest. He's got the best natural sense of humor, but he's never quite found his place to showcase it at SNL. Still, unlike somebody like Kenan, Bobby will have layers to his characters, drunk uncle has a legitimate undercurrent of actual tragedy and likability which enhances…

I actually find Bobby to be the funniest cast member, though he isn't given the showcases like Kate (and perhaps he doesn't want them)

Oh god no. There was a reason there was like no laughing. I remember the Michael Keaton one and that one was solid, it even had him doing that amazing character at the end. That guy is hard to describe, but Ed Norton did a similar character first, but Keaton's was better.

That Donald Trump's girls musical thing had to be a reference to something, right? I only say that because it was so clearly out of tune and disjointed and unpleasant that I couldn't buy SNL thinking that sounded "good". It was just unpleasant to listen to and unfunny as well. That was awful and "get happy" was weird…