The claim has to be false on the balance of probabilities. As there’s no evidence for them, that threshold has already been cleared.

The people on her list have a right to confront her for her accusations to clear their names.

Yes she did. Even if it where only to one person, but of course she published it much more widely than that.

There’s no evidence for the claims in that spreadsheet. No court would hold them to be truthful.

You’re a bit confused there. Are you trying to say you can’t privately libel or slander someone? You’re flat out wrong on that; the obvious example would be giving a harmful employment reference.

I notice you yet again ignored the question: what if it were you on that list? You’re just as guilty as they.

You have absolutely no reason to believe any of that just because someone anonymously added them to a list.

So you wouldn’t want to be able to sue her if you got fired for being on the list?

That’s a difference in degree, not kind.

You don’t see something wrong with someone getting fired/not getting hired because a jilted ex put them on a list?

For that to happen she has to have published it to at least one person willingly.

That’s not the least bit absurd. That would very much be libel if it caused damage.

So are you arguing it would be ok to share her name just with those on the list? Does publishing it a bit less widely make it any less libelous?

Libel is still libel whether she shared it with one person or published it in Harper’s. I’m at a loss for how turnabout is not fair play.

Isn’t that a bit hypocritical? How does that not apply at least as much to the people on her list?

That said, if the dipshit who made the call hadn’t been butthurt over a fucking game, this particular instance of awfulness wouldn’t have happened, so fuck them for starting it.

It’s less than 1/5.

There wasn’t anything to suggest he knew the number of transports. Finn and Rose discussed them in front of him.

That’s a mighty fine hair to split. There’s 61 million between those two.

The UK is a tiny part of the Anglosphere.