I've been talking Higgs all day, so I'd be happy to clear up any confusion you have!

You should know better than to link to TvTropes... some of us have work to do!

Yeah. I miss feeling like it's part of a bigger universe. And these things that you're seeing are fairly every-day occurrences in the Federation. That was what made it so cool when (for example) DS9 was on the front-lines of the war, you were getting to see some of that.

I don't think Superman has nothing to overcome. His struggles are what make the character compelling. But insofar as the defining feature of the hero goes, his defining feature is his humanity. That's what makes him a hero. However, you never feel that doing heroism is a challenge to him. He has other challenges, yes,…

Now I'm thirsty AND in need of some well written characterization.

Very well put sir!

Yeah, starting over is not the problem, the problem is having a Kirk to admire.

Very good point.

Sorry. To clarify, I understand that it is a reboot of the history, what I meant was that this perceived character difference might not be entirely DUE to the reboot, it may just be a younger Kirk.

That's an excellent way of putting it. New Kirk has the swagger, the cockiness of his predecessor, but none of the true confidence and hope to back it up.

The argument could be made that we're seeing Kirk earlier than we ever seen him before. It's not a retcon, more of an origin story. Perhaps in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Cumberbatch we see him both realize how good he is, and hence become cocky like Kirk, but also realize the seriousness of his actions. Thus becoming…

For more info about Phantom Energy, this is an awesome podcast: http://titaniumphysicists.brachiolopemedia.com And one of their first episodes is about this very thing.

"What can I say? I give good wife?"

Hmmmm...I suppose!

The ONLY Q is John De Lancie.... I really don't want to see anyone else in the role. Plus, I'm not sure he would have an interest in Kirk the way he was interested in Picard.

Thanks. Hopefully you find your lost post!

So there are now about 15 threads in reply to this post. If I start a new one, where on the Avatar-chain does it end up? If it ends up at the back, how am I ever supposed to start a discussion that becomes featured, as no-one will see it to reply?

He's directing that, but writing Ant Man. A script has been in the works for Ant Man for a while now, so I imagine it's not taking up too much of his time!

I'm surprised anyone even found this thread!

No problem.. It was damn useful for me to think about it too!