Yeah but we're not even halfway through the run. We've been getting back to Twin Peaks more and more, particularly in the most recent episode. We've already seen the setup of trouble to come for Shelly's daughter and the fact that Shelly is not given a last name in the credits means there's some kind reveal on the way…

I heard the electrical crackle associated with Black Lodge entities when the burnt man was walking down the hallway. Since he's the same one who evaporated into thin air back in episode 2 I think it's safe to say he's not just a random guy wandering around the police station.

Hmmmm. I got that she just felt that Cooper had abandoned her and she was seeing Evil Cooper for the first time. Her "fuck you" attitude didn't seem surprising to Gordon and Albert so it may be that she's always been a little edgy.
This episode also put to bed the theory that the show's various threads exist in…

I loved the original show but instead of reveling in the OTT soap opera I was always waiting for the weird stuff. I'm happy now that Lynch has reversed the equation; lots of weird stuff leavened by some familiar TP humor & quirkiness.
No one can say that Wally Brando isn't classic TP character-driven eccentricity…

Lumping Janey-E as a nagging wife is unfair. She obviously has excellent reasons for her attitude. Her husband disappears for days, hangs out with prostitutes gets them in debt with thugs and misses their son's birthday. That she still shows him affection at all proves that she is not a shrew but just a woman under…

Since I can't shuffle through 1000+ comments, anybody know why Sheryl Lee was in the closing credits as Laura Palmer? I cycled back through the episode but I didn't see her.

This is the best Capaldi season yet and all of the stories so far have been engaging. I thought this episode was fun and only suffered from time limitations. It could have been a great two-parter with the subplot of Missy and Nardole attempting to get back to the Doctor.

They can't have Cooper come to his senses too soon because he would immediately contact Cole and Evil Coop would be exposed accelerating what, I assume, will be the central conflict between the two Coopers. Obviously Cooper does return to normal since clips show him driving a car and once again wearing his black suit.…

People don't just enter the Black Lodge spiritually but also physically. On many occasions characters physically walk into the Lodge without leaving their bodies outside. Cooper, Windom Earle, Annie, Leland just to name the ones I remember. The body that poofed out of existence WAS Dougie's real world body.

Well, the corpse has Major Briggs fingerprints so who knows? It also looks a little chunkier than Dougie appeared to be. Plus Dougie was taken bodily into the Lodge and compressed into a golden ball bearing so there's really no corpse left to reappear.

Well, no one actor, male or female, other than Maclachlan is really driving the story. Cooper is the main character so that makes sense. For every shrew (Doris) and nitwit (Lucy) there is a competent female character. I think Agent Preston is about to step up in addition to the military investigator and the detective…

There's something I've seen mentioned in several reviews that I think is incorrect. Cooper is not inhabiting Dougie's body. Dougie was completely, physically, taken into the Black Lodge before Cooper appeared. Cooper is in his own body. If he was in Dougie's body he would still look like Dougie and he wouldn't have…

I don't think CW Kryptonians have "crack the moon" strength. Superman's strength and abilities have varied wildly over the years. Superman & Supergirl have just enough powers that they can still be challenged by their adversaries.

This comment is really late but I loved the Doctor Who reference when Cisco said "Reverse the polarity of the neutron flow" That was a signature line of the Third Doctor (Jon Pertwee) in the early 70s.

Yeah, the Black Lodge briefly appeared in order to take back Evil Coop but was somehow redirected to Dougie and took him instead.

Don't think so. Clips from forthcoming stories seem to show the Doctor looking at things.

Surely Michelle Gomez would at least come back for a regeneration scene. It would be great to see Idris Elba emerge from the regeneration still wearing Missy's Mary Poppins outfit.

This episode was great with one of the best pre-credit sequences I've seen in a while. The two corpses on uncontrolled spins under the Doctor's voiceover was classic. I also disagreed with the reviewer about leaving the corpses in the suits. Even though they weren't really zombies, they were significantly creepier…

Do you think so? I think her performance is great but it still has the streak of pure insanity carried on from Simm. Delgado's Master was most definitely not insane in an overt way. Except for the obligatory maniacal laughter over the cliffhanger, Delgado was calm, cool and collected like no succeeding version of the…

That's exactly and obviously it. How else would the other students interpret it?