So we get a whole article psychoanalyzing someone based on the comments of one side of a failed relationship? Ridiculous.

Of course, in the context of the show, the joke was that Albert's staredown was an exasperated response to Gordon's goofy behavior and Gordon's response showed his lack of self-awareness.

I think a better idea for using McGann would be to have a story that takes place partially in the past with 8 and the current Doctor interacting indirectly to deal with a crisis. The appeal of an episode where Doctors meet is that you see two established personalities interact with each other. McGann's Doctor, in the…

If Eccleston had agreed to return then HE would have been the Doctor who fought the Time War, still leaving McGann out of it. Many people who've only been watching since the revival are not familiar with the classic series Doctors and McGann, in particular, who only had one televised outing. Barring Eccleston's…

Continuity-wise it would have been good for McGann to be the War Doctor but then we would have missed John Hurt's performance, which was tremendous. Having such a highly-esteemed actor play the Doctor was pretty amazing. It was on par with Derek Jacobi as Yana/The Master.

Who knows? But I have a feeling that both Doctors will end up on a side trip in the TARDIS to have whatever adventure takes up the bulk of the hour. I have heard that this will also tie in with 12's brief appearance in 'Day of the Doctor' when all of the Doctors hid Gallifrey. I think that the point at which the two…

Yeah, Katarina died but she was only around for two stories. Same with Sara Kingdom although she didn't even make it through one. Plus, Classic Who didn't have the emotional depth that the revival does. Sadness might be expressed at the beginning of the next story, as it was with Susan's and Victoria' s departures,…

Any other Doctor wouldn't have the same resonance as the First Doctor. Doctor 1 basically regenerated due to gradual wear and tear so he, presumably, was also holding back the inevitable as Doctor 12 is now. That is obviously the tack the story is taking since he was echoing 12's words about not wanting to do it. He…

I'm not sure there was really a better solution that would make people happier. The Doctor turning back time or some such thing would have been extremely lame. Leaving Bill alive but stuck as a Cyberman would have been even worse.

He's the Master! Of course he wants to.

Not really. The Master has been 'truly' killed at least three times (Planet of Fire, Doctor Who movie & Last of the Timelords) and he has made it back each time.

Great episode. I don't have a problem at all with Bill's resolution. This is Doctor Who, not Game of Thrones. Nobody should really expect that a well-regarded companion will irrevocably die. Adric, the only true companion who was actually killed, was NOT well-regarded and was only one of three companions. At least…

The story is not the greatest but I liked the use of the chameleon circuit in that it worked briefly but still transformed the TARDIS into totally inappropriate items. In fact, if you take out the Cryons and put Peri on mute it's halfway decent. The subplot concerning the people in the middle of the cyber-conversion…

Yeah, the whole bit about Jack Harkness being buried alive and dying/reviving over-and-over again every half-hour or so for hundreds of years didn't work for me. He should have been driven irretrievably insane but he emerged relatively psychologically unscathed.

I believe that the Doctor was SUPPOSED to guard the vault for a thousand years but only did so for about 50 years. He let Missy out early.

You should watch 'Life on Mars'

Yeah, Jacobi was only the Master for about 5 minutes during which time he said a few venomous things, shot a girl and regenerated. Not much to go on. Still….his delivery of "I…..am……the Master!" gave me serious goosebumps when it first aired.

I'm also not loving how BBCA has been completely skipping even shrunken credits and going directly from the last scene of Who into the first scene of Class/Orphan Black. Not even a moment to digest. The electronic squeal that signals the end of the episode followed by the iconic theme over the end credits is just as…

No, the doppelganger is a separate physical entity from Cooper. He is a duplicate holding all of Cooper's memories but is evil rather than good. He doesn't think that he is Cooper, he knows what he is. He is not possessed by BOB so much as he works in cooperation with him as when he says to BOB "You're still with me.…

I think it was meant to be Leland, without the influence of BOB, who suffocated Renault. He thought that he was killing Laura's murderer without realizing that he, himself, was the culprit.