Yeah you guys are right. It's funny: the internal (and quite possibly a hoax) MRN documentary with internal dramatic re-enactments, and the possibility that parts of that are intentionally poorly-written or poorly-acted … it all puts me in a kind of forgiving-of-certain-things mindset that is likely necessary to…

A bunch of great points. Questions like these - shining light on inconsistencies much bigger than anything in seasons past - make me fan-theorize that My Roanoke Nightmare is a hoax, and that the real American Horror Story: Roanoke will involve the consequences of the hoax's production.

Thank you for informing the character design for many of Gerald's new friends.

I think this //was// the finale, of MRN, that is, not of AHS:R, which probably hasn't even started yet.

Actually, I can kinda defend not noticing whose leg was smashed. It doesn't make a big difference plot-wise, it simply serves to make Matt more powerless than if it had been his own leg (because obviously now if he tries anything again, harm will come not to him but to Shelby). It was REALLY hard to see whose leg it…

I've had to keep saying to people around here when they say of the poor dramatic re-enactment "what do you expect, it's AHS" "NO, it's NOT! it's MRN! AHS hasn't started yet!"

I avoided watching the trailer, afraid of spoilers. I'm so committed to AHS that, unless I die before next wednesday, I will watch the episode at least thrice; should I watch the trailer for next week now, or just wait? Thanks!

If nobility wasn't strictly forbidden by the United States constitution, I can't imagine that Jessica wouldn't be Lady Lange a thousand times over by now.

I can't defend not noticing Shelby's ankle … but whoever did the filming/editing of the dramatic re-enactment this week seemed, on my various viewing devices, to not have nailed it in the contrast/brightness area especially in the outdoor scenes at night. I had to rewind several times to be able to see what the hell…

Member when Cartman was obviously the most awful person in South Park!?

Are you guys playing a flute in a tree, or hiding from your wives in a bathroom?

Live action is nothing more than low-budget animation!

Sheila's ultra-supportive wifery lent such additional darkness to Gerald's disease.

I was a huge fan of these AV Club reviews for Ash Vs. Evil Dead.. Season 02 has started, I hope we will see AVC following it?

I'm unclear on what this entire spanning-multiple-articles-and-time story is about. Who raised the issue that Adult Swim hasn't ordered shows from women, and why? So far, it has come across as a "I got you!" sort of thing, which doesn't tend to yield any positive results. Is the author of this ongoing story trying to…

Note that Maggie only spoke in Homer's recollection, which has a consistency of something I love you Marge.

Ever since S19E08 "Sponsored Content" I have felt like AV doesn't feel like making an effort to understand South Park anymore. Luckily, the majority of loyal viewers probably don't need them to do it for us.

I must recommend watching "The Heart, She Holler" to us all. Not only is it quite relevant to this season of AHS, it's also one of the best television series of all time.

Y'know, if My Roanoke Nightmare hires a "real" Cricket, the one from Always Sunny would actually be a really fun choice!

It's not AHS; it's MRN.