The actors playing the actors playing the real people are reading a bad script called My Roanoke Nightmare; it's important not to confuse that script's integrity with that of AHS:Roanoke.

Thanking you kindly. It's wild to see a conversation this long be built on the missing of a very simple missed plot point.

…pretty sure these frequent much-much-more-over-the-top-than-usual shockers are part of My Roanoke Nightmare, not part of AHS:Roanoke.

I wrote almost the same thing about an hour ago after watching Chapter Two (in the chapter two thread) — super glad to see I'm not alone on this theory (because it seems so obvious to me, so much so that I was just shocked people were taking My Roanoke Nightmare as the actual american horror story rather than…

I am so, so shocked at the notion that this season could somehow not be intentionally poorly written. To balance so expertly - on the fishing line between an obvious farcical setup & something a professional critic could take, along with hook & sinker, as a serious if dumb/french-for-shit-by-accident attempt - is more…

This is shaping up to be the most fun & interesting season of South Park so far. I literally weep with joy for that this series exists. It's just so incredibly necessary. So far: A+

Do you have a source for the air dates? It's for Wikipedia; we can't find the whole schedule.

Oh, also: as a crazed Adventure Time fan, I loved the opening gag - long overdue if you ask me! Next year, let's see The Simpsons as Steven Universe and the Crystal Gems please!?

As cool as it would be if The Simpsons would evolve - maybe serialize like South Park has or even become semi-serial like Futurama did during the movies & final seasons - it just isn't going to happen. Having accepted that, this was good and even very good for a 598th episode. I'm very excited to see Treehouse of…

In the words of Matt Stone, "Fuck you, it's South Park" — and I totally don't really mean fuck you at all — rather that's how he described (in the making-of documentary "6 days to air") the attitude developed by the public towards people who take South Park's making-light-ism without a molecule of sodium chloride.…

Member Home Improvement? Yeah, I member! I love to member Home Improvement!

Another fan has suggested that maybe the drink we see Gerald enjoying during every trolling session is Member Berry Wine.

I assumed he just had a Google News alert programmed for "skankhunt42" but you definitely could be on to something; Garrison mentioned as briefly as loudly last week in his campaign montage that he'd fuck all the ads to death, I noticed upon second viewing.

"Like piglets suckling at the teet of a minecraft sow…"

See also: Salt, Fat, Sugar.

Anything by Sousa combined with the audio from Saw 1-7.

It's not gloaty at all in this context, even though it's pretty damn cool. I, on the other hand, was on Facebook as soon as it opened up to .edu addresses. Then, when crap like the game "Farmville" and other premium junk started popping up, I actively tried to get everyone I knew to switch to the at-the-time-brand-new…

Thank you Mythagoras for link, this is really interesting information!

No! Last week's ending I even took as not quite letting Cartman off the hook.. I noticed that we didn't actually see Gerald log in, so it could have been a red herring (i.e. blatant lie to the viewer hehe) … I'm super relieved that Cartman isn't skankhunt, it's so much more interesting that it's Gerald!

When I quit, I left my accounts open & just wrote "i'll be at (a link to my personal webpage)" then turned off all notifications & email etc … sometimes a friend will ask - almost rhetorically, because like you point out, people will think they have died or something - how they can get away from social media (Facebook…