I agree with you but I'm not sure what point of mine you take exception to. I think you are a little off using generational talents as the measuring stick. Guys like Brady, Manning, Rodgers and Brees are obviously the true top tier of the NFL. Tony Romo is an undrafted player that pulled the Cowboys out of that…

He's only first all-time in QB rating. What a terrible quarterback, maybe don't use ESPN sensationalization for your football knowledge in the future.

Go fuck yourself!

Why don't you just admit to be being to lazy to do the critical thinking to understand the sequence of events it takes to win a football game. Counting rings is the most uncreative argument you could possibly make. Just look how well "elite" Eli is playing now that the Giants defense has declined. Same with Big…

To all the fucksticks harping "where are his super bowl rings?"

Ah, so you don't follow "advanced metrics," or as I call them, "tools specifically designed for insight beyond even more flawed and limited traditional stats." You just trust your stupid eyeballs and KNOW Romo is never good in the clutch. (Without citing any specifics, of course.

This is just silly. Romo has consistently produced for ten years despite three head coaches, playing for the most media driven team in the NFL, one of the worst offensive lines and what is now the NFL's worst defense. The guy gets absolutely killed in the media and by his own fanbase while being held to a standard…

Dumbshit fans also think Romo's the problem.

He is consistently blamed for the lack of super bowl wins for the Eagles.

Here's the great thing about statistics, bud: they tend to account for outlier events such as, yes, Nick Foles throwing 7 TDs, in an attempt to objectively determine a particular player's skill and impact.

Gotta be honest, @PFTCommenter does this whole thing WAY better than you do.

the only stat that matters is playoff wins.

You must watch the NFL a lot.

Jaguar41482: Football Outsider's advanced stats DYAR (a counting stat) and DVOA (a "value" stat) both take into account play situation into each snap a QB takes and are adjusted for the defense on the field:

*Wank gestures*

Pretty much everyone says that who doesn't get every opinion spoonfed to them by the White Guys Yelling Sports Media Complex.

Great quarterbacks are judged on stats. Great teams are judged on playoff wins. Juding an individual player for the failings of the other 43 guys who take the field every game is logical fallacy.

Never ask for a meal, of course. Always ask your friend to do something and offer to travel to them. Most people who like to cook would much rather enjoy time in the kitchen than in the car or on public transportation. If you travel to them frequently, they may even feel guilty despite feeding you for free. Just to…

Without them knowing?? Really? Mr. Dachis you are a douche if you treat your friends like this. You deserve nothing good in your life.

I'm incredibly glad you're not my friend.