There are hints in the show that proved John used to be violent with his children. Plus Dean has this habit of hitting Sam whenever he's really mad… Wouldn't be surprised if it was a consequence of being beaten when he was a kid.

Sorry i'm not a native speaker! upset was maybe a little strong?

Yes I did watch all the nine seasons. You know, I think there are different types of criticism, and I don't think mine is bashing J. Ackles in any way. Just to clarify, I really think he's good, that's why I would like to see him up his game. And I can perfectly understand it's complicated to do that with 9 months of…

Not that much in my opinion. His character was a street smart, cocky guy, very close to a young Dean.

Well to be frank, I think he lacks subtlety and I'd like to see him doing something different than what he's always been doing. I saw him in other series and he kind of always gets the same roles. I agree with you though, he did a great job as Dean, but it seems like he could do more. I wonder why he doesn't try to do…

Ackles has potential as an actor, but he needs to do something else. Even if I like the show, it doesn't seem like it makes them grow anymore.

Incoherences, incoherences everywhere!

A bad fanfic of itself… That's exactly that. And sometimes, on the contrary, I feel that some fanfic writers should be hired as scenarists!

I'm a little confused about Dean Cain… (Raah I even have trouble writing it it makes me think about the actor Dean Cain. Oh god why?!) I don't feel the writers really know where they're going, and it's reflecting in the actor's way of acting. Ackles doesn't convince me at all in this…all angry violent thing… It…

I think we should all rejoice for the cancellation of Bloodlines. I'm pretty sure that show was a sign of the upcoming Apocalypse.

Well that's a relief!

Yes maybe…

I really liked this episode, especially after Bloodlines.

I liked him in Dollhouse too.

Yeah so is mine. Unfortunately that wouldn't be a huge surprise…

This episode was such a cliché and it made Sam and Dean act so much out of character that it could have been a part of "Changing Channels".

Is that bad if at some points I was just fast forwarding until I saw Sam and Dean on screen? :D

I totally agree! And you're right, I realized how charismatic Ackles and Padalecki were when I saw them in this episode…

Hahaha that's excellent!

Even her terrible eye liner?