agree with Astra, they really have not even given us an inkling what they are doing on Earth or what they are up to. They established maybe she foresaw Krypton's demise and was a terrorist to get them to see they were in danger (the old she is a bad guy, but was right trope), but their motivations now are completely…

I have to admit, these reviews for Supergirl on this site are rather spot on. I like this show and the things they have nailed down are really good, but there are a lot of weaknesses too that need to be smoothed out as the series matures. The whole superman thing being around but not showing up is a huge hole for me…

They look so identical when they were together, I thought Cat would just then shift to accusing kara and Supergirl of being twins.

That is a huge plot hole for me too. He is way too competent and good at computers just to be schlubing away at a magazine. It defies logic, its like a waiter who is friends with the main character just so happening to be an expert sharpshooter in a spy show. He seems to be a kind of deux ex machina for getting…

Has there ever been a resolution to a murder mystery on a show handled more poorly? A cop comes by and tells us (rather than shows us) that some woman we never met confessed to the murder so they are off the hook. How did this plot even get on air? They would have almost been better just acting like it never…

The last book will come out in 2030 when everyone will have forgotten all about the HBO show and it will be new to his long time readers because they will be 70 years old and will not even remember how the story started. He is out foxing all of us. lol

One of the things I never liked about the show was it is way too PC for a period show. To me, why do a period show if people are going to act like it is 2016? There would have been a lot more drama if everything you and Mandelist said if it was "not fine". The Earl is very remarkably progressive about social issues…

This episode actually had good writing, which is rare for this show. It is a guilty pleasure for me, I like watching it, but do not think it is good (like a soap-y walking dead for me). I have no idea why they keep getting nominated for emmys besides they like anything with British accents.

It is inconsistent. The only "real" world explanation I can think of is no one cares what Edith does or who she screws around with. Wasn't she left at the alter? Maybe the press feels bad about it and gives her a pass. lol

Really, I am surprised the family is not a laughing stock already. All his daughters have been bad at love in this series. Even the one that died married her chauffeur. I believe the entire point of having daughters were to marry them to prominent families that would have strengthened their finances, like the…

well, I think she is supposed to be. And she is the prettiest one left in the cast so there is that.

losing what? what are you even talking about? Who is winning? Its a TV review discussion. Go back to the media matters or daily kos site, you are in your bubble there.

When I saw Lady Mary's hand shaking, I was amazed as this was the most nuance this show has ever portrayed in six seasons. They actually did not even call attention to it. I almost half expected her to say "I was acting tough, but I was so scared" to be consistent with the show..lol

Fair point. But the characters have been kind of bland so far with Holden and the former crew of the Canterbury.

Unfortunately, not on this site with TV reviews. Every single one I see, the reviewer is more concerned about their SJW credentials and how diverse or PC it is or is not rather than reviewing, you know, whether the show is actually any good. Just check out the SNL reviews to see what I mean.

good point. I do not really think it is a good idea for any age group. If you are younger, you are better just staying single if you want to see what is out there rather than trying to have an "open" relationship with someone. In 2016, it's not like people are being pressured anymore to get married at age 22.

Chinese Democracy was a good album, the problem was that it came out wayyy too late. If it came out in 1995, at least a couple of the songs would have been well known radio hits like some of their other stuff. Its basically like when Def Leppard or the Rolling Stones make a new album, it might be objectively good,…

It looks ugly and shows like this that deal with a political issue almost never work. If you hit both sides of an argument, you get the criticism above that its toothless (see also criticism nowadays about South Park and their last movie "Team America"). If it does take sides, it is hated by half of America and is…

Maybe, I think being in an "open" relationship just doesn't work at all unless people have been married a long time and the romance is gone and they do not want to get a divorce for whatever reason. If you want to see other people, just do not get into a relationship if you are young.

I actually think his advice was good. You can set whatever boundaries you want in your relationships. If the guy is ok with his GF hooking up with other woman, but not dudes and he told her that and she (originally) accepted it, she has to live with it or it is cheating. Giving him a speech about it doesn't do…