As we've seen, much of those five years were not in fact spent on the island after all, and of the time that was it was mostly either: (a) dating Shado, (b) fooling around with Sara, (c) drinking beers with an aussie.

And equally importantly, once she was in a relationship with him, did she change her mind about her motivations? As Paint Chips above says, the most likely reason for confronting Oliver about it was because she genuinely cared.

Laurel was excellent… towards the end.

More than that, it's a long game so that when Curtis does get killed he can turn to Felicity and say: "See? Next time we do things my way."

Yeah - Malcom might lose more than his hand next time if he tries that.

And then the war between the Interdimensional Council of Moiras and the Interdimensional Wells army cross paths with the Interdimensional Council of Ricks and all Hell is well and truly unleashed.

It's genre awareness rather than common sense, I think.

Yes, you have repeated it hundreds of times. In this thread alone. It feels like you account for about a third of the comments on this article. But no matter how many times you repeat it there is no fundamental objective law that Susan has lost the right to break the truth about Oliver because she has slept with him.…

Anything is, if you have the sword and John Wick has whatever else.

Related, I loved the scene where a contract was put out on John Wick and phones started ringing across the lobby and everywhere all at once..

Yeah. I described it to my friends I went to see it with (who hadn't seen the first one) thusly:

I think they tried to type "fucking" and failed. :(

Well, the person Oliver killed who knew his identity was a murderer and a kidnapper. Susan Williams is an investigative journalist (one of the few remaining on the planet, it seems). So you may or may not consider the first scenario ethical but there's certainly a very great difference between the two scenarios. The…

"Susan is in her right to REPORT it to the police. NOT WRITE ABOUT IT."

Really? Based on what? She looks slightly older than him.

If you want to strip whatever happened to its barest bones, I see it as a
woman (Thea), getting an unethical reporter fired due to her unethical
activities. That's the simplest way to put it.

Cat Grant realised, but not because of them looking similar. She had most of a Season where that had no effect. In fact she's even starts looking at Kara more closely and visibly wondering if they could be the same person. Given that she's seen both of them face to face multiple times, that's actually supporting…

Double bluff. "She was blonde, officer, but it looked like a wig."

You don't give up freedom of action or the right to accuse someone of something because you have sex with them. She hasn't "lost any rights."

Unpleasant.