Jon did leave the Night's Watch. He didn't betray and destroy it. There is really no comparison there. And, by the way, this was after the Night's Watch literally murdered him.

He swore allegiance to Robb Stark, then betrayed him, destroyed his home, and made his two brothers homeless while trying to kill them. This ultimately lead to the death of the youngest Stark. Theon himself seems to accept that he was in the wrong. From Jon Snow's perspective, there's not much Thein could say in his…

I can respect that consistency, considering you have the word "evil" in your name.

She was jealous of her daughter in law, who made her son happy and was good to the people, so she allied herself with the Septim to try to take her down. Then, when that backfired on her, she killed a huge number of people to avoid a trial, including her daughter-in-law.

Come on. Was Ramsey Bolton a morally ambiguous character? Joffrey? Yes all the characters are flawed, but this show has straight-up bad guys. Cersie is one of them.

How can anyone watch this show and not have a definitive rooting interest against Cersie Lannister? She's as despicable a character as has ever been on television.

Are people really torn on who to root for? It's easy; root against anyone fighting for Ceraie Lannister. She's easily the most dispicable character the show has left. I can see hoping Bronn doesn't die, but to hope he beats Dany?

I always got the impression the Lannisters were not militarily strong. For example, they needed to have the Tyrell's bail them out in defending King's Landing. Here they are able to wipe the Tyrell's out completely as if it's nothing. That, along with Tyrion suddenly being dumber than Jaime and Ciersie, was a little…

My struggle with this episode is that I don't remember the original series well enough to know if I'm supposed to know all these characters. During the Aubrey conversation, for example, every time they said a name I wasn't sure if I was supposed to know who they were talking about. Same with the final scene. I know…

I skipped Season 2 (watched the first half of episode one and decided to read a recap instead) and am enjoying Season 3.

I'd like to know what consequence selling part of your soul has. Is there a limit to how much of your soul you can sell with no consequence? Could you sell 99 percent of your soul and be just fine with the 1% you have left?

I get that the final scene was played like Theon chicken out, but I think that was his best move. If he attacks, he gets his sister killed and probably himself too. This gives him a chance to regroup and find another way to save her.

My first thought for the suitor's "gift" was Tyrion, but I don't see the plot going that way. My official guess is it will by Arya. She's headed there anyway.

Of all the terrible things about this show, and they are legion, the one I cannot abide is how this stupid, worthless family immediately becomes the focal point of every group they stumble across. The leaders of these groups immediately forget everyone they've been leading for months to focus on this stupid former…

Tulip being anti The Voice is a necessary plot device. They need to have an explaination of why he doesn't just immediately use The Voice to get people to do what he needs them to do. Otherwise everything would come to easy and the stories would get repetitive.

Based on what Miller is saying, this was not written to be the end of the character. They wrote it so he could have a reduced role next year (because of his schedule), but when he read it he thought it was the perfect ending.

The call from the IRS agent didn't just delay her quitting the police force. I don't think the initial resignation letter was just her quitting her job; it was her leaving law enforcement. She had given up, thinking evil had won. The call from the IRS agent restored her hope, her self confidence, and likely her…

That was a good episode. I hardly said "who the hell is this, now" at all.

Was there an explaination that I missed for why Fish kid napped Penguin only to forgive and team up with him? Or why Penguin got so attached to Fish he was devastated when she died? They were enemies like a week ago.

These might be the most egregious example of the "main character joins established society and immediately becomes it's centerpiece" TV trope ever. Maybe I could buy Troy letting the family stay, but why is he so focused on them over all the people that have been in the camp for a long time. This family is not…