I see both points of view, and I think that part of the problem is Scarlet’s drag: she’s continuing to paint herself like a Disney villain, and those kooky antics and exaggerated faces that look so adorable (and I admit it: Scarlet is GORGEOUS both in and out of drag) on the boy look vaguely creepy and disturbing on a…

For a moment I read your comment as “ungayed” and thought “well, that’s ironic for a Drag Race comment!”. Thanks, as always.

Untucked: continues to be great.

Uh, I wouldn’t go quite that far, sis.

All Stars 6 has been excellent so far, but this episode felt heavily produced, which is an unwelcome return to form after what has been, perhaps, a brief foray into authenticity reasonable edits by reality TV standards. I’m hoping against hope that Kylie isn’t being set up for a Finding Her Voice edit with a win next…

Kylie’s rendition of Steven Tyler was both sexy and hilarious, I loved it. Kylie and Trinity embodied their icon the best

Ginger should have taken her place simply because ‘Geronimo’ is a horrid song for anyone to cover.

Props for another excellent recap: you’ve covered off most the points why this episode — which was really pretty good — felt like it fell just a bit short of the standard that’s been set in other episodes of this very good season. I agree that Jan deserved the win, but that TKB presented the only performance that…

I don’t actually expect either queen to win this season, but I’m still rooting for them both.

Ru seemed positively gobsmacked by Silky’s name being ru-vealed

I guess that I can see that, but Bianca’s edit was as complex as these things are allowed to get, and I never saw her myself as a simplistic villain or bully. She got a huge amount of airtime — and really, along with Adore, was the heart of the season — and was one of the few queens on this show who have ever been…

And somehow they forget that Yvie Oddly was instigating a lot of crap with her unwanted critiques of other queens.

I actually saw Adore in season 2 of All Stars (which I chose for more Katya content) before I saw her original season. It was weird because in AS she comes across as whiny and a quitter (noping out in episode 2

She let it all get to her and just amplified until she was unwatchable. Throw in the fact that producers smell blood in the water and either gave her an even worse edit or refused to give her any redemption in the edit, whatsoever.

I was starting to feel really badly for Silky, but she’s actually had a great run on this show. She’s not only been able to project herself as a likable, sympathetic, and fully-rounded queen, but has likely garnered a large amount of fan support which she’ll be able to use to legitimize her placement when she…

This was the best episode of All Stars for ages, and possibly since season 3. It continues to amaze me that the show is letting the queens self-produce — and get to frame their own narratives this season. Let’s note that no one is getting the Villain Edit or the Delusional edit at this point; Yara is getting the Yara…

Laganja did more for herself here in three minutes than she probably did in the entirety of the six(?) episodes in which she originally appeared! She was so incredible that I had to watch that lipsync twice, and TKB was no slouch, either. That was amazing.

This is the best thing about doing deep dives into the first seasons of Drag Race for the AS cast: the kids have all grown up and out from the cartoon caricatures with which they were first represented on their respective seasons and many of them now realize that they have more to share than soundbites, memes, and…

Is it fair that on a talent show the win went to Yara bouncing a pair of rubber saggy tits?

as the All Stars pool gets more and more shallow