And PepBut's bitch-slap. So deep. ;)

Honestly, I think it's probably the latter. Just think, maybe AT will teach a whole new generation great lessons in a subtle way (hopefully). Maybe I'm just being optimistic, though.

Peppermint Butler is the candy version of Aleister Crowley.

My opinion is that if the fans are getting something good out of it, go for it. For instance, if you pledge 5 bucks and get a digital download of the album, or you pledge 20 bucks and you get the actual album and a shirt, OK, that seems fair. I do get really tired of the "Pledge 50 bucks and get a napkin that we…

I thought it felt like season 1, too, especially Jake's appearance. But then again, I like the first season a lot.

This was a great episode all around (sans Andy, who, as someone pointed out, was stupid but painless). However, the best part was the note drop. I remember watching "Christmas Party" when it first aired, and at the time, Jim writing that note and then taking it away was really powerful, because it showed that he…

Considering the documentarians made it, it is plausible they just made a typo.

This reminded me of an episode from Season 1 or 2. Good stuff.

What I don't get is that this, easily one of the best from the last few seasons, gets a C–, whereas "The Farm" gets a B? Wut?

I also appreciate the return to form on some of the humor. For instance, when Jim and Clark are having their fight, Clark says something (I don't even remember what it was at this point) and Dwight, quietly and off-camera, says "Burn." This reminded me of 'back in the day' when the humor was more realistic and not IN…

I totally agree, and as Detective Fork mentioned, while the karate stuff was a little cartoony, they managed to pull it off in a believable way… and they had some funny moments thrown in, like Dwight's "FIREBALL!" and Pam using something like the Force to convince Dwight not to punch in her face.

This was easily the best episode of the season, and possibly of the last two seasons. I'll agree that the last half of the season has not really been that great, but this one was. It hit all the right notes with Jim and Pam, and the Dwight plot was what the fans have been waiting for.

I felt like this could've fit in nicely with a previous season. It had a 'vintage' goofiness to it.

That was the darkest most humorous part of the episode. BMO, just standing there with a smile, announcing that it did not have conscious thought when its batteries were out.

I agree. The strange tempo and the off-kilter emphasis makes BMO more believably a robot. I'm glad they used someone of Asian descent for the voice, because a vocoder would just be stupid, and the Asian accent is just kind of funny at times (for example, "Jake, you drive a hard burger" is adorable in BMO's voice).

I meant finish the subplot. Don't end the relationship. But yeah, end the nonsense too.

I'm a late-Office apologetic, but tonight was not good. They only have four or so more episodes left, and they need to STEP UP THEIR FREAKING GAME. Enough of the cartoon. Finish the Pam and Jim subplot. End it already.

"The Sixth Extinction II: Amor Fati" was also going through my head when I was watching this episode. Gotta love me some X-Files!

"The Last Temptation of Finn" anyone. The stories are sorta similar. Sorta.

What's up with the CMO cameo?