I think you're misremembering.  One person (Eddie) bought the peanut butter and then Jeff announced that everyone could share it.  After the orgy, Jeff announced, in an almost perfunctory way, that anyone who had twenty bucks left could get a letter.

I'm gonna go with "necrophilia".

I was stunned that Cochran didn't outbid Malcolm for the "information."  I hope he was banking on the fact that there's almost always a challenge advantage, and it's almost always one of the last items up.  It's the only explanation.  Even that he screwed up, and got lucky that Eddie didn't promptly outbid him.

Yes.  It was ridiculous.  Malcolm and Cochran both played it poorly and got incredibly lucky.  Eddie and Reynold were complete disasters, and none of the others were much better.

Oh man, I forgot about that.  No way Phil has forgiven and forgotten.  That's gonna be a frosty, frosty Ponderosa.

Hell, I'm not sure I'd perform better than Francesca.  

Malcolm got beer and that clue, too.

I'd bet he realized his mistake right after speaking, but by then it was too late.  Also known as "the story of my life."

@avclub-2378677b42d71f3f051d32bfaf88c1d7:disqus To me he's reading more as "giddy" than arrogant, but I can see how he'd come across that way.

I was replying to Other Guy's supposition.  JGL can't live up to Sinatra either, besides being, like Tatum, way too young for the role.  I mean, I like him, but come on — it's Sinatra.

Godron-Levitt could be a good Sky Masterson.  No fucking way in hell Tatum lives up to Frank Sinatra, or anyone to Stubby Kaye.  In summary: phbbbt to this.

What if it was Cedric the Entertainer homeschooling two precocious, wealthy white kids?  Who have a sass-talking robot butler voiced by John Ratzenberger, and their mom is lonely young widower/uptight heiress Anna Chlumsky?  Huh? Huh?  Would you kickstart that?  Cause I can set up an account in no time.

Hmm.  Erotic verbal abuse?

That`s kind of sweet.

What about paying in hugs?

It's supposed to be about big men! In tights! Both physically and mentally!

I'm calling it now: End of season 1, Joe, Ryan, Claire (and possibly Emma and a few other randoms) get swept out to sea on that damn yacht.

As a Canadian, I was always under the impression that under these circumstances Americans would hole up in their homes with their massive stockpiles of Second Amendments and shoot the living hell out of anything that came close.

Bake him away, toys.

Wise guy, eh?