The opposite from Chuck, who coldly conceded that the pain of Jimmy's remorse was real, but since he's decided Jimmy is irredeemable, completely devalues that pain (and Jimmy's love, or indeed any of his good qualities).

No, but Nathan Fillion and John Hodgman were in season one of HarmonQuest. Close enough?

And actually appropriate for role-playing a (probably neutral-neutral) assassin, as well as for Peyton just wanting the game to be over.

What Sarah said: Harmonquest is the show you describe. Dan Harmon leads a group with a few funny, D&D-experienced friends, the DM is good, every episode has a different guest (some with D&D experience, some just with improv experience) playing a quest-related character, and there are (inexpensive but expressive)…

Depending on which version you go with.

'Stine said "We don’t have to keep feeding the darkest parts of ourselves," not Noah.

At least Rectify got to finish out its story (as Orphan Black will this year), which is more important than awards. And it did so beautifully.

He got a Double First in his college at Cambridge in Spanish and Arabic, and apparently speaks like half a dozen other languages as well.

And exactly two people were correctly encouraged by Highmore's casting.

That wasn't luck, that was smarts. The casting was topnotch throughout.
Be fair to January Jones—I agree she wouldn't have Norma Bates in her wheelhouse, but she's good when cast right. She's been great on The Last Man on Earth.

Suicide by brother was a pretty brutal thing to do to Dylan, but the flash forward would suggest he got some top notch therapy afterwards.

Finally saw the episode, couldn't miss the Hugo!

Oh, it was exactly a Hugo Award. And an older one, since in recent years (or decades) they tend to have fancier bases. I said it out loud when she picked it up—"What, that's a Hugo?" You don't expect to see them outside of your Hugo-winning friends' mantels. (Like watching the movie "Mom" and Albert Brooks's character…

When someone says "You're doing this to yourself," odds are, they're doing it to you. But I didn't trust Claire from the moment she made Gabrielle give her her passport to be locked up in the safe. Just, no.

I didn't play the episode expecting a one-woman show. Brilliantly done.

Yes.

Agreed. I never thought I would care for Teddy, but my heart breaks for him now (as it's breaking for Daniel, and Tawney, and Janet…). He's not perfect, but he's human and he's finally doing the best he can.

You realize that "the large majority of women suffer internally from abortion" is a myth, right?

Not true. Pigs do take mudbaths, to cool off and protect their skin from the sun and insects, but they never shit where they live, unless forced to by humans.

I haven't read the source material, but your Possible Spoiler Warning seemed like the only logical assumption to me.