Definitely. I think she was slowly letting her true colors show, and her true colors are batshit insane. I think it was just done slowly, because he wanted him to still love the "real" her, instead of the Cool Amy that she had made up. He then gradually realized she was a completely different person, and didn't have…

I got the sense that the driving away was a result of her trying to show her true colors, and him not liking what he saw. I think showing him that was intentional (she wanted him to love her for who she really was), but her intention wasn't to drive him away. The young student part was cliched, but I think it's a…

Also, to what extent does someone's poor behavior have a cause/effect relationship? Not that I'm saying cheating will lead to unhinging an already sociopathic spouse, but does he deserve any blame for it? Are they unrelated and we should just blame him for being a clueless asshole who cheats? At some point, are we…

True. I think "slutty" because the characters all say it so much, and she tried to jump him at Go's house right after Amy went missing, but I think at the end of the day she's just young and immature and fancies herself in love. I think there are some moral ramifications that come with sleeping with a married man…

I have - it's just been so long since she's been in something with that much depth that I forgot all about it. I wish she did the offbeat movies like that more often. I'm officially Team Reese for Amy now!

I have, and I had completely forgotten that was her. I think she could definitely rock Amy. In another thread, Charlize Theron was suggested, and I think she could definitely do Amy justice as well. I just need to know who our male eye candy will be.

Classic, haughty douchebag from a movie, which is basically how Nick is described. I think Bradley Cooper, or maybe a Josh Duhamel. Natural haughtiness with the ability to be charming past it is completely required.

She HAD already framed Nick though, had poisoned herself and saved the puke, and accused people of pretty heinous crimes. This was the next step, and didn't seem too sudden or a break from her character. On the other hand, no other real way to get rid of Desi (aside from not having him exist in the first place).

I like the innocence of a Reese casting, I'm only afraid that she won't be able to bring the psycho part of her to life. Naomi does have the right look/haughtiness that I imagine Amy has, and likely can bring out the sociopath. Good call.

I dunno, I think Andi came across as slutty, and a bit delusional that Nick could be with her while his wife was missing, and/or that he would have eventually left Amy for her if she hadn't gone missing. She did know he was married the whole time.

The women did come off horrible in this, but I didn't even think about it until after I was done. Everyone appeared relatively nuanced - aside from Amy, no one was all good or all bad. The men don't come across all that great either, and the author makes it clear that the false rape accusations, false stalking…

I'm just glad we aren't being asked to read Fifty Shades of Grey, like every other damn book club is doing!

I'm sure more than one of us immediately purchased after last week's Worth It. Mine's just waiting for me on the Kindle...