@brida: Bright Falls is a very good series of vids - but WHY did machinima have to RUIN IT with their inane comments pointing things out. Gah :(

V1 all the way.

@Vysion: relax it was a replica

@Zunnoab: as I said he did some good games 20 years AGO.

@wahrugene: nope try 20 years earlier. Yup I am and he should've been retired along time ago - I'm not wearing rose tinted specs here just never liked his games really.

Shig Miyamoto. I know I'll be unpopular as hell but Wii Music?? Plus a sheadload of other uninspired games for years. Mario is also one of the worst (dullest, unispired) game characters ever - he lends virtually nothing to the story or plot of the games apart from some pipes, Thats it. Could be replaced by…

@DSForte: how can that be in a list of greatest PC games of all time? It can't, not even in an ironic sense I'm afraid.

Avalon is a masterpiece. The wehole concept of what is reality pisses all over the ham fisted Matrix films.

@LucasFFXI: yeah so the two houses SHE OWNS say she's not got money?

Sweet, High Citadel by Desmond Bagley, The Spy Who Came in from the Cold by John le Carre, The Door into Summer by Robert A. Heinlein are 3 excellent books, must read the others

Bugger missed opportuntity being in GT5 considering it would be a much better fit in Test Drive Unlimited 2.. Imagine races like they do on the show, plus of course the test track, etc. MUCH more fun and at least the AI wouldn't be horribly wooden and predictable.

Ooooh The nasty (respected, well liked and talented) PROFESSIONAL WRITER disses your favourite franchise! Must have hissy fit.

puppets and good CG work very well - check out Hellboy 2 for the perfect blend of the both to make amazing effects.

is that Gordon Frohman? [www.hlcomic.com]

Smallworld, Citadels of and definitely Ticket to Ride (pref Europe edition)

@Killer Toilet: only MULTIPLAYER support for original Xboxes - Nothing to do with originals or anything else on the 360.

@catterwall: like burnout paradise in the way that it was 10-20 times the size of burnout paradise, had a great driving mechanic and menu system to quickly choose what you wanted to do + much much more.

great little game and 1000x better than dishwasher as that was to me rather poor

@I_Like_TDs: the multiplayer is graphically simplified over singleplayer in pretty much every game to decrease lag.

I really think that Kotaku not having Batman: Arkham Asylum as an option on the vote meant it didn't get in the top three (yes you could write it in as your vote under other but people are lazy).