They did sell vinyl before. I got my copy of Donna Summer’s I Remember Yesterday from Columbia House (back when the LP was originally issued.). And before me, my father used to get 8-track tapes from Columbia House; it was his main source for buying tapes.

This! I thought the show was trying to be a remake of Greg the Bunny but with the Muppets. And frankly, I’d be on board with a Greg the Bunny reboot (but only if they gave him back his button eyes.)