I figured it wouldn’t make the list but Mr. Robot has some really great music selection. A lot of them are not on YouTube but this was always one of my favorites. Such a perfect scene.

“No Children” was used much better in Moral Orel:

Playing twins will come into play

How many different ways can we possibly watch Elizabeth Moss suffer? I guess we’ll see!

Apart from Seehorn I’m sad Zoe Kazan didn’t get a nom. She was awesome.

I have no idea why people think Climax was good. That movie was hot garbage. The Suspiria remake was great though. 

Completely agreed. When I watched it for the first time, I was prepared for a silly, boring movie that didn’t live up to the first five minutes, and by the end I was baffled that it had garnered such a reputation. It absolutely pays off the ideas from the opening montage and then goes on to seamlessly add additional…

I’ve actually never cried during the montage - despite what others have said, my identification with the character is not yet strong enough to elicit such emotion - but THIS scene is the one that hits hard and gets the tears going.

I’d say the genius was in the way they DID build the world with clear rules, without doing so obviously. How zeppelins and giant birds are established in the news footage, how the insane lifting power of balloons is shown off the first time we see Carl’s cart, even stuff like the “snipe hunt” and Russell’s GPS…

This scene destroys me far more than the opening. He spent so long thinking he let her down, but she was truly happy with him. Guts me. Then the two chairs left behind. I love it. Anyone who says the rest of the movie isn’t as good doesn’t pay attention to scenes like this. 

Yeah, I just don’t agree with that at all and I wish people didn’t take it as such as given. There’s absolutely wonderful stuff in the whole movie that builds on and pays off the themes set up in those perfect first five minutes.

That scene gets too little attention.  I lost it for a second time during the movie when this scene was over.

This ^
This scene hit me even harder than the opening one. 

I love the talking dogs and I think the first five minutes lends transcendence to the entire movie.

god, Carl’s expressions are so subtle. And very Spencer Tracy.

Agreed. I would have to sit and think about my Pixar Mt. Rushmore, but I at least know which movie goes into the Washington spot.

Pixar has made plenty of good movies since Up, but I still think Up is their magnum opus that they've yet to surpass.

I had to watch the whole movie again…I just love it so much

"I like that "Peggy Sue" song. It's my favorite Buddy Holly song."