...which makes punching someone in the face totally justifiable?

I’m not sure what your point is.
And I’m not sure who you’re arguing against.

I’m no doctor...but why would getting punched in the chin give him a black eye?

Joey Bats is having a down year so far, but, uh he’s still got a wRC+ of 128, which means he’s batting 28% better than a league average hitter.

Currently there are literally only 50 players creating more runs with their bat than Bautista.

There are at least 3 players with .300 averages who get on base LESS than Bautista…

The team was charged an out on the play. And there is no provision in the current rule that calls for punishment beyond the on-field punishment of an out.

Welp, I’m convinced.

Regardless of the the weakness of the rebuttals, you’ve done a shitty job of actually making a logical argument for your case.
You’ve stated your opinion, and then (justifiably) mocked anyone who questioned it (because the response so far have been weak).
But, frankly, you haven’t convinced me that results don’t and…