You know what, I just replied to your earlier post (a bit harshly, for which I apologize). Disregard it. I guess you and I just have a difference in opinion and that's that. We'll just agree to disagree.

I'm guessing that you, either, can't be bothered reading my posts or are refusing to acknowledge my point.

Oh, you're definitely right. If we didn't have a system of checks and balances, there would be no accountability and authorities would be able to abuse their power without consequence. However, the public need to act in accordance with the law as well, not feel entitled or act above it without knowing full well, the…

I don't think you fully read one of my earlier posts...? I did say that she has a right to refuse ID, however, that only pertains in circumstances where a cop asking for ID is incredibly random and unnecessary. It does not apply to the current situation, where the cop's legal right stemmed from responding to a callout…

I'd think that if there was reasonable suspicion for any matter involving the police, that suspicion should be (at least slightly) acted upon. People's lives have been saved because of further questioning, or working on a hunch. In any case, I guess this story is interpreted differently by different people :)

Yes! Very well said!

I'm saying this from a legal background. I've also spoken to friends who are lawyers, and they agree that, technically, the fact that the cops were responding to a callout, would constitute reasonable/probable cause to investigate an alleged crime. If they'd gotten on the scene, saw nothing overtly suspicious, and had…

Then I guess I'll just be going with this: there are always two sides to a story. Then there's the truth of course.

Thank you! I just can't with some of these replies in this post.

Apparently (well, according to the witnesses anyway), they were doing a little bit more than kissing. Just saying...

No; I make an attempt to educate myself on the law and the extent of the law, so that if something like this happens to me, I won't end up like her. Or probably like you.

I love your assumption that the police wasn't going to let her go.

To be honest, I don't know if I'd necessarily think that its odd. I've definitely heard some more bizarre stories than this. I could be wrong however ;) I do know though, that she was criticised on here recently due to accusations that, she failed to make it in pop, so she just jumped into hip-hop. That, her whole…

What about the witnesses though, who pretty much saw them screwing in the car. I'd take a little bit of liberty with adults coming across this; most of them would likely brush it off. But wouldn't it be at least a little bit offensive to kids who may pass by them (assuming of course that they were indeed, screwing…

You are very right on that one. From the transcript, it seems to me that she was just being stubborn and unco-operative, not to mention, entitled, when simply showing ID could've made this situation 10 times easier for all parties involved.

Very much agree with this; also, I've said this before, but according to law, the cops were legally entitled to ask for ID simply since they were on a callout to investigate an incident. This isn't like a cop stopping you on the street for no damn reason and demanding you show him ID in some kind of weird display of…

I was just going to mention this in relation to some of the (ignorant) posts above, claiming otherwise. Normally, a cop can't just stop you randomly on a street and ask for ID (at least, not in California); however, if a cop is on a "call out" to investigate for whatever reason, they have a *legal* right to get your…

Just curious; what is so weird about her story. Not supporting her ('cause frankly, I don't think she's got the talent nor the brains), but what is so strange about her moving to the States to get more opportunities in the entertainment industry?

I agree on that, and if she was indeed, then props to her for making it an issue :)

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree then :)