Lots of people watch it obviously, but not nearly as many of those as you would think do so without finding a ton of things to complain about.  

Can't we like his interviews and his stand up but find the seeming randomness of the intros boring?  It wouldn't make the guy boring, it is just difficult for most people to do intros of that style well.  Scott Thompson, who I also love, has trouble with it too.  Is that such an unreasonable complaint?

I agree with most of this except that he does have some experience doing voice work.  Obviously, that isn't acting, but he has some idea of what it is like to have to work with others as opposed to ramble on without restraint.  That might be enough of a base to build on, but perhaps not. 

I haven't been into tv as much since I got my miniature Christmas tree.  Why watch tv when you can stare at a Christmas tree…..that's miniature!

I actually liked hearing him ramble on about miniature Christmas trees or Adam and Eve.com.  He is an awful salesman, never more so than about those sponsors.  

@avclub-79c971df9097228e547f2661f55b9847:disqus , your friend is either a bad stand-up comedian or a dude who jerks off too much.  Not that those two are mutually exclusive categories. 

In the literal sense, this is very much radical.  Terrible, but radical. 

I will think of something to say for you: this sounds terrible.  You ARE welcome. 
ETA: I hang my head in shame, theCzarChastichbasTurd.

A developer is having a civil argument with a fan.  Not only is this a first in game discussions on the internet, it is the very definition of a reasonable discussion. 

Since I haven't tried this yet and am going by my experience playing Flower, I will have to cede some of your points about the review.  I still think a relatively novel approach to a co-operative multiplayer game deserves something beyond ordinary praise, particularly if it has been executed well. 

I believe ICO spent five or six years in development because the developers hit the ceiling with the PS1 and decided it needed better hardware to run the game.  I really hope that isn't the case this time. 

Let's not start complaining about continuity now.  We haven't seen the Persian neighbors in ages and we don't really need closure on that matter either. 

It wasn't just a semen-in-the-eye-joke, it was a semen-in-the-eye-by-way-of-tubesock-turned-fleshlight joke.  Well done, AD writers. 

Reviewers will generally never rate things as high as fans, even those fans who can be critical enough.  I think Rowan's reviews have been entirely fair. 

No, the splitting of hairs was necessary.  The line as you correctly got it is much funnier. 

Freddy had the line of the episode for me: I gotta quit these…and this…but I'm too much like my dad. 

It was Roger dressed in cut-offs and a half-shirt while he hit on Jeff the whole episode.  It could have been Mark Wahlberg or just a gay stereotype.  

If you have to watch a dog die in slow motion, making him 'die with dignity' softens it at least.  

While I would place that as the best sad story about a dog, the Simpsons' had the best happy story with Dog of Death.  As a dog lover who generally likes stories about pets, this episode was a fine contribution to that list of animated pet stories. 

No movie had ever succeeded in making me feel stupid for not knowing what was going on like that one.  Thankfully I only had to watch it twice to figure it out.  Abe was the name of Aaron's sled.