That episode definately deserved an A. Going to AVClub's page after having watched it, I was saying to myself "if this isn't an A, then what is"

Hang on how did the grade just come down to a B+?

Hang on Wut? Didnt they say something like "sarah has a few hours to live", so she actually isnt quite dead yet?

I know that he knew. I am just not okay with the fact that everyone just accepts murder instead of incapacitating him.
Ramming the knife in the dudes leg would have done just the job. The knife guy really wasn't any danger.

The show really missed out on Dean's ridicolous killing of the man. He like properly violently stabs a guy for no apparent reason. And everyone is just kind of accepting it. Sam gives it 3 seconds of doubt and then moves on to being mopey.
Definately a big chance missed there, as Dean really went a bit out of…

The Snooki thing probably disappeared because they heard the outcry of fans as to how horrid the decision to even let her close to Supernatural was. Sometimes they can be reasonable, can't they.
Thanks for not letting Snooki on the show!!!!!