I’m an attorney as well and just went through the whole car search with a slightly larger budget. Had a 350z, then my son was born. Ended up with a new 2016 Maxima, which I say puts out the “Classy but not pretentious” vibe you are looking for. The m37x is a good choice too, in fact an m35h was going to be my next…

I’m a partner at a law firm and drive a 350z. I get nothing but complements from other attorneys.