I'd agree with you if I felt the intention were there:  If Reed were either playing provocateur (he clearly is not), or indulging in a movie critic's version of Thompsonesque Gonzo (also, clearly not), I would find the whole thing amusing.  Who knows…maybe he IS a genius and took a bar bet to fire up the threads at…

Harry Knowles over at AICN wrote a negative review of Inception, and admitted in the middle of the review that he fell asleep for half of the movie.  He gets hilariously torn up in his talkbacks about it, and the funny thing is, he defends himself, not realizing the irony of reviewing a movie about dreams and the…