I've been reading these all day and THIS is the BEST one I have seen! terrifying. truly. I don't think I could have stayed another night in that house.

Yep, this is the scariest one. No contest.

"Look At Me" is the scariest story I have ever heard, bar none. The scary/crazy people stories are much more frightening to me than the ghost stories. And "She Never Left" was very well-written, and I found it so bittersweet...I don't believe in ghosts, but in a way, that longing, lonely child-ghost, who never left,…

LOOK AT ME IS FUCKING TRAUMATIZING!

Yup, and that crazy fear is why I will NEVER EVER EVER have my desk with my back to the door. Me and my roomate in college arranged our dorm room specifically so that neither of us would have our back to the door.

I cried at the end of "Look at Me". I actually shed tears of pure terror, here at my desk at work.

"Look at Me" wins, hands down. This was me at the end:

I work from home so I'm alone all day, and I usually shower on my lunch break. I desperately need to shower today and I now regret reading "Look at Me" because I'm TERRIFIED right now.

And if "Look at Me" is the scariest then does that mean that humans are scarier than ghosts? I kind of think so....

Seriously. It took my breath away. I'm not sleeping tonight after that story!

Yup. "Look At Me" wins. Ugh!

I still have goosebumps from Look At Me.

Holy. Shit. "Look at Me" was so scary I realized at the end I was sitting with my hands covering my mouth, feeling like I was about to hurl. And I'm sitting in a lit office, with my coworkers benignly chatting nearby,

HOLY SHIT, LOOK AT ME??!!! LOOK AT ME?!!!?!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. Was it a ghost? A person? I can't! You win! I'm freaking out over here!

Oh. My. God.....

this is ACTUALLY the MOST scary. holy craps!

WINNER! AAAH!

Sweet jibbering jeebus, this is the scariest one I think, and I've read this entire thread. This should have more stars/be higher up. They never caught anyone?