We all love GOT and are passionate about our favorite characters. That is what brought me here. A lot of times I read but not post. Glad you weren’t one of those that wish harm on me because we have different viewpoints. I just can’t deal with that type.

BTW, I love Davos too and yes he was too devoted to Stannis. I think Sansa should be more dubious of Littlefinger than Davos. When one has saved the life of (or helped bring back to life) a loved one and the other has sent me to be mutilated and raped, I think I am going to have more trust in the former even if I do…

Right! But what about Sansa not mentioning Littlefinger to Jon so that Jon may have a head’s up on Littlefinger. After what Littlefinger did to Sansa, I would not meet with him in secret or ask for his help. He had her believe he was trustworthy only to hand her over to Ramsey. Littlefinger killed Lysa, had Ned…

*healthy^

Sorry. New to the forum. Some of the replies may be duplicates because I did not realize that they were in pending status. Also, I like a health debate so don’t take anything personal. I just wasn’t a big fan of Catelyn and Sansa seems to be heading in the same direction IMO.

While Tyrion’s kidnapping was not the reason Ned was killed, it was the reason he was nearly killed. Had he not been stabbed in the leg and dropped to the ground before Jaime could finish him off he would have died. I only blame her for the things I mentioned. Not White Walkers. I guess I never liked her from the way…

Robb broke the oath that Catelyn made for him without his knowledge/approval. Who would want to marry one of Frey’s daughter’s (something Catelyn should have been asking herself)? Catelyn told Ned it was okay to trust Littlefinger and he did. Catelyn convinced Robb to go to the wedding when he was reluctant and he…

Oh, it was Catelyn who convinced Ned to trust Littlefinger and he did.

I do agree with some of your points. Ned nearly died when he was confronted by Jaime and would have had he not been stabbed in the leg and dropped to the ground before Jaime could finish him off. Remember, Ned told Jaime he had Tyrion kidnapped to cover for Catelyn which now made him an even bigger target than he…

Honor the wedding contract she set up? Kidnapping Tyrion without a plan? Treating Jon like crap for something not his fault? Advising Robb to take his pregnant wife to the wedding? I do not believe she gave great advise or practiced good judgement. Advising Ned not to go to KL was the best advise but when the King…

Catelyn kidnapped Tyrion (without Ned’s knowledge) and when confronted by Jaime, Ned said he did it to protect his wife. Review season 1. If Catelyn had a better plan instead of kidnapping Tyrion because she believed he harmed Bran, Ned may not have died before making it back to Winterfell which is what he was…

Agree 100%

I am not feeling Sansa. Every time I think I am ready to call her badass she does something to negate it right behind it. I am getting the same vibe I did about her as I did Catelyn (her mother) causing the deaths of Ned, Rob, herself, and many others. Off topic, why was he called Ned instead of Edd. Just asking.