Home alone at night, had to stop reading the stories after I read yours. Heebie jeebies galore. Well done.

See this is so much more terrifying than fake imaginary furniture stories. The scariest thing to happen to me was I went to a concert in a not great part of the city and all the parking was on the street and apparently street lights hadn’t been invented yet so it was dark as balls. Decided to leave early and on the…

What is up with these creeper dudes being terrifying but having the chillest exit lines? “Don’t worry, I’m leaving”?? “Don’t mind me”?? Like if you are hiding in a woman’s house then say “I’ll see myself out” when caught that will just cancel out the breaking and entering?!?!

This is pretty far from the same thing, and not exactly scary, but once my sister and I both had the same dream at the same time. In it, we were in the one tree of the backyard of a house our dad was living in at the time. We looked up and saw a very angry squirrel, which then started coming down the tree at us so we…

Mine isn’t scary, not really, but kind of creepy.

Didn’t contribute this on the original thread because it isn’t really scary, mostly just weird, but what the hell, it’s almost Halloween.

Criminy, that’s awful!

Fuck that shit. Drive to the police station and run inside!

OMGGG NEVER LEAD SOMEONE TO YOUR HOUSE JFC

It absolutely was. There were a lot of “and it turns out it wasn’t a ghost but someone was actually in the house” ones this year, and I don’t think I’ll sleep properly ever again for a while.

That was an excellent selection. Although I wish it was one entry longer because the one about the guy on the Craigslist date with the guy who worked real estate and was making noises in the basement was terrifying. I thought about that story for DAYS after I read it. Scary as hell.

I had trouble with cops showing up to my new to me condo saying I’d called 911. We didn’t have a landline, didn’t even have a phone, so it was definitely not us! I don’t know what actually happened to finally resolve it, but those were weird calls to make to the phone company. They wanted my account number. I don’t…

Am I allowed to have a second submission? This story was relayed to me by one of my best friends. Back in the late 70s, my friend’s mom was a student at UNC. She had a car on campus, and went home on the weekends fairly regularly. She lived in the country, so when she went home, her route was often unmarked pavements…

So I submitted one before but didn’t realize that I could submit via the comments (thought I forgot my password! I didn’t )

I did the same one year. I went on a real spree and read the jezebel thread then went on 4chan/x/ where they have all the creepypasta. I was a very grown adult, but I made my boyfriend sleep with the lights on that night. He was not happy.

When I was young our house was broken into and I noticed the intruder hiding under my moms bed by looking in a floor length mirror she had. Guess who’s not a fan of using a bed frame?

For me it’s the fact that he was so controlled about it that he could be like, didn’t go according to plan? K, boldy say bye and head out for the next round. GAH. So much premeditation.

Thanks for picking my story!

FINALLY!!!

No, that’s fine, I never needed to sleep again anyway.