and don't forget all the mucinex commercials.

yes! i was close to yelling 'snickerdoodles' at the tv. i did avoid them for years because i assumed they were like a snickers bar, not knowing the soft, chewy, cinnamon sugar goodness i was missing out on. fortunately i have changed my ways.

there was also the whitney abortion storyline on the affair.

always forget to check my disqus replies! but i'm glad i wasn't alone. i also thought it might be just using two different babies which is common, but it seems odd given that on this show, everything else that doesn't line up is done on purpose. that would be one mega oversight, or yeah, very strange decision at…

in my experience most men would rather have the women worry about birth control (esp before getting snipped - i know men who don't ever even want kids and yet refuse to have it done, probably thinking on some level it takes away some portion of their "manhood" and that seems pretty noah) and that is true here too…

and with whitney weighing approximately zero pounds, you think you'd notice something like that.

c'monnnn, i read through all these 100 comments almost entirely about discrepancies…and not one about the different baby alison has in the courtroom vs. the one she has in the lobby? i need answers, man! or, you know, at least theories :)

yeah, i agree with beema. i watched season 1 last year on a whim on ondemand, and i was hooked pretty quickly. if you aren't i would abandon ship, though. it is a little heavy on the sex scenes very early on, but quickly revealed real content beyond the HBO factor* imho.

ha! yeah, i guess i've just always been that way, the quiet observer. i also have mild ocd and notice in my own life when any little thing is changed. it's honestly annoying to me most of the time, actually, but once in awhile it serves me and is satisfying. :)

you are leaving out the part where he's known her forever and they've been close. if he met helen today, yes, he probably wouldn't give her a second look. but there are decades of built up longing here. that colors how most of us see people, heavily. i don't think it's about helen looking good, or looking good for 40,…

"I'm not one that notices the memory discrepancies between the stories much"

i'm not a huge noah fan, but when he threatens his awful bitch of a MIL i found that immensely satisfying. i would not categorize that as one of the many things that makes him look bad. especially after the MIL clearly states the kids aren't home, and then baits and needles him the whole time until he finally reacts,…

you know, i did notice her duckbill this season, which is funny because obviously alison is the queen of duckbill. so i guess, much like real life, some guys really have a type. :p

the scene with his youngest son made me cringe, but it's so complicated. he's just coming off this insane interaction with his mother-in-law (very satisfying to me as a viewer, actually), who he already knows is doing her best to poison his kids against him, and then he finds out his [ex] wife told the kids he'd be…

i was looking for the episode two review, also. i watch everything via ondemand or download so i didn't realize it hadn't "officially" aired yet as it is available on ondemand.