I just want to say as a not-fat person with large arms, I would ask my costume designer to please, not put me in sleeveless things. Really, the actor can have a say in how they’re dressed. Has anyone asked Beanie how she felt about her costumes?

It’s quite possible Beanie asked for the more modest costume. I don’t like waving my bat wings around either, and I’m not even under intense public scrutiny... 

It’s one of the awful truths of being a female human: If she's not really really pretty, built like a sex symbol, or so ugly people can’t look away, a girl doesn’t really get seen. I have no problem believing that no one recognized Becky in Poppy as plain drab Becky probably never registered much visual attention…

Yeah, all the reviews/recaps across the site have been getting really bad for basic, factual errors in the last few years.

I always suspected her because no sane person would willing have that godawful haircut.

Everyone in town would have at least seen pictures of her by that point. It would have been a huge risk for her to be there.

Agree 100 percent. The whole season was just a mish mash of cool scenes, cameo appearances and catchphrases that added up to a whole lot of nothing in many cases.

The show seemed to imply that Becky was the type of person nobody paid attention to before she disappeared and she reappeared in a role which nobody paid attention to.  All she really had to do was avoid her father and the mayor

This one has been driving me crazy in the recaps all season long: At absolutely no point in time did anything in the show say that the phone number they were texted from belonged to Det Williams.

Also, she wasn’t using Det Williams’ phone. The trio just *assumed* it was Det Williams (as in who else would be helping them?)

D- Season

Although Cinda’s Nickelback line was funny, they’re not a one-hit wonder. Generally derided by critics and hipsters, yes, but they have a bunch of hits.

To be fair, the Jenningses disguises were rarely if ever meant to fool people who already knew them. They were used so that their marks and witnesses would not be able to give useful descriptions. What Poppy pulled off was the equivalent of Philip faking his own murder and then showing up at the travel agency as the…

I think it’s more “they cleared the possibility of her being the murderer after the blackout.” Hopefully she’ll be back for S3.

Oh cool a review posted an hour and twenty minutes after the article on the homepage spoiling Paul Rudd’s cameo was posted. Great job, AV Club.

Let me add I would give Season 2 a D Minus and send the writers back to the writing room for a major re-write!

Absolutely terrible finale.

And to a lesser degree Lucy. I was still hoping that the misheard “14 Savage” meant that the murderer was a 14-year old Savage (Bunny not understanding that Lucy wasn’t ever Charles’ official stepdaughter and never had his surname).

But shout out to Adina Verson for acing the killer supporting role she got.

Did the show just forget about Nina?