what are you, fucking mentally retarded?

Need mr robot in here

fair enough, but one nitpick. in 2011 eli was absolutely top 5. i don’t care if the stats show it or not, he was the MVP that year, all year

guess i’ll have to cry myself with the jerseys from the two championships i got to attend live :( :( :(

You’re a total dipshit. Eli Manning was the ENTIRE Giants team in 2011 (along with Cruz and Nicks).

This is the dumbest shit I’ve ever seen

Hey look, that’s all fine, and there are valid reasons he should not be in the HOF (though if Namath is, I’d argue Eli should be also for that reason alone - similar selling points and Eli was much better).

That’s a nice list of QBs you have there who are “better” than Eli. As a Giants fan, you can keep that list, and I’ll keep the rings he won us.

Well no shit, he’s started games for the same team for 13 years. How is that a “great stat”?

Defense did NOT drive the Giants 2011 SB season. That defense was pathetic during the regular season, and though they were better in the playoffs, that entire season was on Manning. Manning has never had a HOF caliber look to him (though he’ll get in on accumunlation basis).... BUT, in 2011, he was truly a HOF caliber…

I think Beningo and Roberts are fair to the Gmen to be honest. But other than that, I agree

lol @ Odell signing with the Rams. That’s the dumbest shit I’ve ever heard.

2 fluke plays? Manningham’s play was NOT a fluke, it was one of the best passes in SB history given the spot. On top of that, people conveniently forget the incredible escape Manning made on Tyree’s helmet catch. Or beating Favre in the snow in Lambeu in the second coldest game there. Or the 15-1 Rodgers team on the…

excellent record

yep, as a Rangers/Giants fan and Rutgers alumni, this sports season has sucked

as a new yorker, thanks for the laugh, that was cute

There’s no good sportstalk radio *anywhere*.

When I heard this live, I had a feeling it’d end up here a couple days later. I actually like La Greca a lot, he’s not as bad as far as NYC sportstalk radio hosts go

Fuck yes Brand New

I wouldn’t call Decker shitty