Hudsucker Proxy is an excellent choice but mine would be The Life Aquatic. Edges out Rushmore and Royal Tenenbaums as my favorite Wes Anderson even though it has the lowest metascore of any of his films.

It's always a pleasure reading a Nathan Rabin movie review. Sounds like this piece of crap needs to be seen to be believed (of course, once it's released on netflix). So glad you're writing here, Nathan. Looking forward to many more reviews!