Your last point would be an interesting one to explore with Julia, but I feel like the decision still didn't work for her character because even if we broke her mindset to how being shadeless would affect her thinking (logic based for morality), it's difficult to comprehend how sparing Reynard was the most logical…

I feel like after everything Reynard did, the fact that Julia didn't shoot him or Our lady Underground (who just stood by and let her son do all of that) is irritating, and for her reward to be getting her shade back is…I don't know. I understand what the situation is supposed to represent for Julia's character (in…

Thank you! Plus, I feel like Julia losing her shade in the process of trying to kill Reynard throughout the season was a better idea in concept than execution, because aside from a couple of extreme instances (blowing up the trees and throwing Quentin at Reynard), I feel like they just made her more or less the same.…