I love your story! As someone who has awful, vivid nightmares almost every night, it’s nice to see someone find a way to relieve theirs. Do you think the box would be cool with you sharing a picture of it? Would love to see the creepy little buddy!

I’m so with Tyler - “Oh hell no” indeed! YIKES.

Oh my GOD. *full body shudder* Good, good Libby. I’m so glad you brought her to safety with you!

AGH! OMG, the footprints coming out of the frozen lake! That’s a good one.

And Jameela herself has Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, so kinda checks out! Just chiming in to second your yup.

Same here! I’m really bummed about this news. 

I cannot wait to look these up. Thank you!

/puts on sunglasses. YEAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!

Ha ha! I guess I’ll just have to let that particular mystery be.

I love that!

I had forgotten about this! Also, I can’t thank you enough for reminding me of Martin Short’s Jackie Rogers Jr. character. That man can just disappear into the weirdest fucking characters, and I love him. And JB as the Captain was perfect.

SERIOUSLY. These motherfuckers are in charge of everything now. How *exactly* are they “silenced”? And really, how were they ever? Because I don’t remember that ever being a thing, unfortunately.

Mama 4: Momo Mama Mia: Here We Go Again

YES! My husband and I still refer to Ryan Reynolds as “Berg.”

Me too! She’s a badass with a killer mind and golden voice.

I don’t know if you’re still on here, Sorcia, but I come back to this story every year. And I have to say, especially after this year’s batch of “scary” story “winners,” this one is UNDEFEATED. Fucking 7 years later, I think of this when I wake up at 3am. God damn it.

Your story is giving me the heebie jeebies, wow! The arrows in new woods are a great idea, by the way - as long as no one is following you and trying to get you lost, anyway. I’m sorry that you went through that, but I’m glad you’re ok, and thank you for sharing.

This is so, so sweet. I’m fighting back tears here. I’m sorry for the loss of your grandpa - he sounds like a genuinely special person.

Oh, you and the person who shared this are angels. Thank you!!!

Smart! I would want to be in your group if life were a horror movie.