"Number 1 Must Have" might be my favorite S-K song, and that's saying something.As far as records go, I'd probably put AHOTBO at #2 behind The Hot Rock. But that ranking also changes depending on which one I just played. Ignoring the debut, One Beat is always last for me, then the rest rise and fall based on recent…

We're talking about Foo Fighters. The album that made me abandon Foo Fighters was "Foo Fighters."

I'm always amazed when people discuss AFTP and don't discuss "Find the River." As sweeping of an epic hook as the band ever pulled off.

"Chase this Light" has 4-5 canonical songs. And plenty of crap.

I don't think Grohl's made anything of note since "Everlong." And before that, "In Utero." Foo Fighters are the Boston of our time.

$6 is a phenomenal price for a bomber of Imperial Stout.

Ok, I'm fascinated to know which Jesus Lizard song.

IT WAS AND IS GREAT

"Garden State has become a laughingstock." Only to cooler-than-thou music writers.

I really hope this album here doesn't mean it didn't make the year end list. It absolutely needs to.

Of all the random things to be offended by, what killed me was the author liking all the generic, overproduced Snow Patrol records and none of the genuinely quirky and interesting ones before. About knocked me over in my chair.

The way you are hearing it is correct, Yoga.

I realize the idea is to lessen not grow your music collection, but Josh you really ought to check out New Radiant Storm King sometime. I discovered them back in the early/mid 1990s, when they did a split 7" with Guided by Voices. They're outstanding.

Yeah, one is really missing out not owning Challengers and Brill Bruisers. Essential recordings.

Good god, what a horrible review. "Album is great, singer doesn't vote the way I do, D." AV Club cannot seriously let this guy do more reviews. Give him a political column, fine.