I would switch the ratings for the first two seasons and call Season 5 a B+/B but otherwise agree. Wish I could stop humming tunes from the show and feeling let down though. Damn you NBC! Give us our closure!

Thanks Todd. The show has left me with such an unpleasant aftertaste and your post expresses those feelings in such a nice, balanced way.

I think it is better you remove the grades completely. It adds nothing to the review except general confusion regarding where the episode might have fallen so spectacularly short. Even when not compared to season 8 or 9, season 2 is par excellence and your grades are not reflecting that.