So they're both "A" episodes, you just don't like them?

Repilot: B+. Not the funniest Community ever, but had some great jokes ("Isn't this kind of weird without… you know… Magnitude?") and I love when Community is willing to go to dark places. Dark both tonally and visually - does Dan Harmon have a lighting crew that he rehired as well? Either way, it looks way sharper…

We're actually kind of close to "six seasons and a movie" being a real thing. How did that happen??

I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not. As a huge Spider-Man fan as a kid, that is definitely who he is in the comics (well, not helping others is only the origin story), and that's also who he is in the movies. Which is why I've always been super-confused as to why people hate "Amazing Spider-Man" as not true…

After this episode, this might be one of the most compelling Final Fives in Survivor. Usually there's at least one really weak (in an uninteresting way) player, but this season everyone theoretically has a shot and everyone's super-interesting. Tyson and Gervase go without saying. Monica's got the whole challenge…

Highlights:
* Season 1 finale
* The entire Pegasus arc, which is probably my favorite thing the show ever did.
* Season 2 opener (which really could be shortened to just "Season 2," which seemed very clearly to be the high watermark in quality to me)
* Season 3 finale. Baltar's trial was gold. Also, I didn't mind the…

The miniseries was far less enjoyable to me than the rest of the series. I think it may have just moved too slowly for my tastes. "33," the start of the first season, was where I really got hooked.

I'm finishing up Battlestar Galactica this weekend. I've been slowly working through it all summer (well, actually: slogging through the miniseries for half the summer, devouring seasons one and two within a week, and then slowing down for - but still enjoying - seasons three and four), but now I'm in the final four…

The ending of "Man of Steel" was the pure antithesis of "Tread lightly."

@avclub-0ae7484a9f3bbd2a21df420050c032ae:disqus That would be the greatest TV show episode ever.

So you're saying that "zeitgeist" is in zeitgeist right now?

Beads?

Unfortunately for the Lord, His days are like a thousand years.

Also, this is the only season where I'm not angered by the lack of a Community nomination.

Justified for Outstanding Drama Series.
Timothy Olyphant / Walton Goggins for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series.
Will Arnett for Oustanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series.Survivor for Outstanding Reality-Competition Program (don't laugh. It had two arguably Top-10 seasons this year, and it got beat by a…

Withdrawn!

Good point. Props to the producers for resisting the [likely great] temptation to cast a Hantz duo.

The dog bar confessional might have been the confessional of the night.

Rob C? Awesome.
Tyson? RC? Could be fun.
Kat? Aras? Rupert? Meh.
But seriously, who ARE those other people?? It's a natural side effect of bringing back people so often—you run out of actually interesting new people from regular seasons, and you kind of grasp for straws. Then again, it worked well this season (Andrea…

Eddie displaying competence talking about the IV made me double-take in a big way. Where was that guy during the last 36 days?